115 vs 124 Grain!...9MM Speer Gold Dot Self-Defense Ammo Ballistic Gel Test & Review!

115 vs 124 Grain!...9MM Speer Gold Dot Self-Defense Ammo Ballistic Gel Test & Review!

Tools&Targets

1 месяц назад

52,351 Просмотров

Ссылки и html тэги не поддерживаются


Комментарии:

@mariodesmo
@mariodesmo - 19.10.2024 07:59

I aways wondered where/what the gold dot was, that's in the ammo's name. lol

Ответить
@v.german11b
@v.german11b - 19.10.2024 09:15

Extraordinarily well done. It was an excellent assessment that opened my eyes. Appreciated!

Ответить
@barrydraper
@barrydraper - 19.10.2024 17:33

Excellent reviews! Your testing si so consistent and fun to watch! Nicely done. Personally, I'm more of a Federal HST kind-of-guy...

Ответить
@adquinta
@adquinta - 20.10.2024 07:17

Test some of those G2 rounds through clothing. Curious how they do.

Ответить
@007twm
@007twm - 20.10.2024 16:47

I like the 115 gr Gold Dots. As always a great video and thank you.

Ответить
@robertmajors1737
@robertmajors1737 - 21.10.2024 02:55

The 124 hst is what I keep in all my 9mm, from 5" to 3". Gold dots are good bullets as well though.

Ответить
@rickyroost7732
@rickyroost7732 - 21.10.2024 06:03

Is greater penetration always better for self-defense ammo? It seems like these types of tests assume that. It looks like the gel block is about 18" long. If the ballistic gel is meant to simulate a human target very few people are 18" thick. So the possibility of pass thru and injuring a bystander seems higher with the greater penetration round.

Ответить
@muffemod
@muffemod - 22.10.2024 06:21

115 smoked the 124

Ответить
@davehemmerly8496
@davehemmerly8496 - 23.10.2024 00:22

124 all day

Ответить
@JoeBuck-uc3bl
@JoeBuck-uc3bl - 23.10.2024 03:33

What about Silver Dot 136 grain vs Bronze Dot 148 grain?

Ответить
@eoj5683
@eoj5683 - 26.10.2024 02:00

So is the perp anymore dead cuz 1 was 1200 ft and the other 1150 i mean i dont get it 🔫🔫👽🇺🇸🍕🍔🐽🐷🐖🔥🦅🦅🦅🦅

Ответить
@rsbreeze
@rsbreeze - 26.10.2024 06:54

Gold Dot!

Ответить
@IVORYPaultx
@IVORYPaultx - 26.10.2024 16:16

Exactly why I choose 124gr HST over Gold Dot. Also, my guns prefer Federal ammo.

Ответить
@lescocat1501
@lescocat1501 - 26.10.2024 18:19

They make 124+P makes up for the Velocity

Ответить
@johnnymccann5607
@johnnymccann5607 - 27.10.2024 09:33

nna 1inch 32gr stinger 771 fps, 42 ft/lb 2in 940 fps , 63 ft/ lb. 2in yellow jacket 33gr 945fps, 65 ft/lb. Phoenix hp 22with 3in bbl stinger 32gr 1070fps 81ft/lb. yellow jacket 33gr 1003fps, 71ft/lb. I don't own or will own mouse 22_25 guns. now in comparison Beretta Tom cat carbon 60 gr jhp 1000 fps, 130 ft/lb. ruger 380lcp 2.75in 90grjhp 988 fps, 195 ft/lb. next round ball loads I experiment with 44 sp, 38sp, 357mag. for pure penetration they can't be beat.i didn't have a cronygraph then but speer data I used was the rou nd ball loaded for 4in barrel around 560 fps. my 44sp was 3in. at 10 yards shot easily through 3 gallon jugs of water. the round balls having little friction surface works like a drill bit. I think I'm doing to try 9mm and 380acp tests for penetration. if I remember correctly accuracy inside 30 feet was acceptable for self defense. papa wishing you well. 😊

Ответить
@delwingreen1767
@delwingreen1767 - 27.10.2024 18:59

I'll stick with 165gr gold dot

Ответить
@8654ZuluFoxtrot
@8654ZuluFoxtrot - 28.10.2024 21:21

I think the most useful info in this video was the penetration and expansion comparison of these two rounds. The #1 thing I see most civilians not understanding, when discussing self-defense ammo, is this one point....We don't want a lot of penetration. I run into a ton of people who think a heavier round or more velocity is what you want. The reality is, when considering a self-defense load, is reliable expansion and NOT over penetrating your target. The truth about real world, not Hollywood, is that 99.9% of any self-defense shooting is around 2-4 rounds shot at close range with usually less clothing than what was used in the testing in this video.

You have to also consider FBI gel is NOT supposed to be 100% accurate when comparing to a human body. FBI gel does not have empty cavities, bones, tendons, etc. If a round exits a gel block, especially when you use a heavy clothing barrier, it's far too much penetration and should not be considered when choosing your self-defense round. Personally, I like to see around 8"-10" of penetration, which you won't see too often when choosing a 9mm, so get it as minimal as you can but still expanding completely.

Ответить
@ron8566
@ron8566 - 28.10.2024 21:24

Nice test. Thank you.

Ответить
@mmrlightning
@mmrlightning - 28.10.2024 22:47

I am new to gun ownership but I am so confused by this video. To me, the 115g did better in the test because the bullet traveling is faster and doesn't penetrate as far (meaning reduces the chances of the bullet exiting the target) and when it did enter the gel it made a larger wound? I am reading the comments and a lot of people are saying the 124 G is the winner but how are they coming to that conclusion? What am I missing?

Ответить
@giantdog1
@giantdog1 - 30.10.2024 02:13

124 gdhp+p edc here

Would like to see this round in caparison with the 115 gdhp+p and the 124 and 115 hst

Ответить
@arthurdirindinjr1792
@arthurdirindinjr1792 - 30.10.2024 02:38

Excellent straight forward no BS no semantics just solid extremely relevant and equally useful information
I have carried Speer Gold Dots in everything from my 9mm Shield to my 9mm P320's, 9mm PDP's 9mm Carbines and 45acp's about 10 years ago stumbled onto a unbelievable bulk buy on all caliber Gold Dots and I just about maxed out a CC buying them you can not ask for more performance from a PP HG bullet than a Speer Gold Dot
Shot gallon water jugs at 100 and 200 yards with my 9mm Carbines and performance was impressive
I once set up a 2x4 at 300 yards and hit it 4x out of 4 with my 9mm Carbine and all four God Dots blew completely through sure wouldn't want to get hit with a 9mm Gold Dot at even 400 yards

Ответить
@Vladpryde
@Vladpryde - 30.10.2024 03:47

I have three 9mm guns for self defense/home defense: a CZ P10F, a gen 5 Glock 26, and a Glock 45 (the G45 is my only currently-loaded firearm). I always gravitate to the mid-range weights because, while I had a Glock 22, I was always of the opinion that a 165gr load at 1,140-ish FPS was the perfect balance of firepower (or capacity) and velocity. I traded that G22 for the G45, and now I'm carrying over the same beliefs.

I like the 124gr loading in +P velocities. I'm looking at both Federal HST and Speer Gold Dot 124gr +P loadings. This test really helped, so thank you. I might go back into Armed Security, so I should probably make up my mind soon. Or just buy both and see which one is most accurate. But I think, with the Speer Gold Dot, in 124gr weight it would definitely benefit from +P velocities, given the velocity results of this video.

Ответить
@pilotmiami1
@pilotmiami1 - 30.10.2024 16:47

Go ahead

Ответить
@phatboizbackyardkustomz9006
@phatboizbackyardkustomz9006 - 31.10.2024 06:37

I think most ammo is pussified anymore

Ответить
@chaos-jp7nt
@chaos-jp7nt - 31.10.2024 18:08

I like how humor 😂

Ответить
@tacd962
@tacd962 - 03.11.2024 21:33

165 GD, HST or Ranger T 40

Ответить
@lzxray6781
@lzxray6781 - 03.11.2024 22:03

Buy a box of gold dot 9mm bullets and load your own.

Ответить
@lzxray6781
@lzxray6781 - 03.11.2024 22:06

I use Fort Scott 125 grain TUI in my EDC.

Ответить
@Darkmattersfrank
@Darkmattersfrank - 03.11.2024 22:30

You’re like me. I like hot rounds too. I run +p+ for my carry gun.

Ответить
@nicksilva4415
@nicksilva4415 - 04.11.2024 03:50

124gn +P Gold Dots chrono at 1182 f/s through 3.7" bbl Kahr CW9.

Ответить
@AJohnSmith
@AJohnSmith - 04.11.2024 16:40

The lower speed is to increase expansion, not penetration. The quicker it slows, the bigger the wound cavity can expand outward.

Ответить
@Cruiser777
@Cruiser777 - 04.11.2024 18:03

I like that Liberty round that you had a few months ago, 2200 ft 50 grain +p😅

Ответить
@mattdean7109
@mattdean7109 - 04.11.2024 20:27

I'm late to comments but don't forget about barrier performance. 124gr will do slightly better. Faster isn't always better. Sometimes, that means over expansion and less or unpredictable penenatration. There is a sweet spot and the 124gr hit it. Minimal less expansion, a tad more penenatration. Possibly less muzzle flash and less felt recoil. Do a comparison with the G19 and 124+P vs the 147. Then add the results of this test with them. 😉

Ответить
@allentraylor5659
@allentraylor5659 - 04.11.2024 23:27

why would you think a heavier object would be faster ?

Ответить
@allentraylor5659
@allentraylor5659 - 04.11.2024 23:27

i'll still take the 124.

Ответить
@paulmeek7964
@paulmeek7964 - 05.11.2024 05:42

Shoots great in all 9s and preforms excellent use 124+P in handguns and 147+P my scorpion. Zero complaints.

Ответить
@AlanToon-fy4hg
@AlanToon-fy4hg - 05.11.2024 13:38

Big Ammo is scared of any potential civil liability.
Also, less powder, more profit$...

Ответить
@BB-gr9hq
@BB-gr9hq - 06.11.2024 22:46

I consider them both winners. With Gold Dots you get sealed primers, nickle plated cases, and a reputation for performance.

Ответить
@sjc3081
@sjc3081 - 07.11.2024 06:17

The 124+P Gold Dot factory loading does 1230 from my S&W 5906.

Ответить
@SharonMiller-o4p
@SharonMiller-o4p - 07.11.2024 21:41

Seems the 115 does better than 124 ,and 147 .silvertips

Ответить
@bigmike8808
@bigmike8808 - 08.11.2024 05:32

You just taught me something I’ll remember my whole life. Thank you.

Ответить
@peelreg
@peelreg - 09.11.2024 01:50

So often I look at your test and think I want to see it. Great job! BTW, did that 22 pistol with the barrel leading problem get resolved?

Ответить
@larrydeters9732
@larrydeters9732 - 10.11.2024 21:46

Thank you for the clear and concise tests. Much appreciated.

Ответить
@keithdaniels1994
@keithdaniels1994 - 10.11.2024 23:44

My carry is an XDM with a 3.8" barrel. It groups better with the lighter ammo probably due to barrel length. Nice to see I'm not giving up much in performance.

Ответить
@Dharqness
@Dharqness - 12.11.2024 13:22

manz just talks like he is filling up a 500 word essay

Ответить
@backcountryoverland103
@backcountryoverland103 - 12.11.2024 21:59

124 standard pressure GD in my EDC's. Main reason is when I was active in LE that's what the department issued. They have their reasons that it is a preferred round. Now as a civilian I follow that lead so that if I ever have the misfortune of a self defence situation and my ammo choice is called into question, I can say I had many years training with it, and it's what an agency determined was the best choice for use in public. Last thing I want is having some crazy hot +P stuff a procecuting attorney can have a field day with. I am confident standard pressure Speer, Federal, Horniday and the like will serve most folks well. My outdoor / woods carry will differ based on that need.

Ответить
@mobilegamersunite
@mobilegamersunite - 13.11.2024 06:28

Got 147gr hollowpoints for around 34.cent and never looked back, im glad i ordered thousands of rounds of it.

Ответить
@gregorysloat4258
@gregorysloat4258 - 13.11.2024 10:44

For all your criticism of the Gold Dot 124 grain round (full disclosure: it’s what I carry), I bet you wouldn’t want anyone shooting at you with it. 🤣

Ответить
@thisismagacountry1318
@thisismagacountry1318 - 13.11.2024 10:58

Ever do 147?

Ответить