The ULTIMATE Big Brother Winners Tier List

hey everyone! i see a lot of comments about taylor's placement so i am just going to say this instead of replying to each one:

i 100% see your take when it comes to the michael move. it worked out because she won. i just view it as so risky because there was no way to know she would have been chosen by monte and turner over alyssa. so to me it's like taking out michael was riskier because it could've resulted in getting fifth (as opposed to second with a chance at first if she kept michael.) again, i realize it's a hypothetical so i do see all of your opinions when it comes to why it wasn't a bad move!

and her social game was terrific i agree. i would consider moving her to the top of the needs some improvement tier, but i don't think i would add to the solid game tier, as everyone else in it i believe played better.

thanks for watching!!<3

A runner up tier list could be fun

WHERE ARE YOU? YOU HAVEN'T POSTED IN LIKE 5 YEARS WHAT 😭😭😭

In my opinion, Chelsea would be a bit lower. Don't get me wrong, I like her a lot, and she should be in the top category but a bit closer to the bottom of it. She really did switch a lot with cam and Makenzie, I think she trust Makenzie to much and I'm surprised she got no votes because she was such a comp beast, and Chelsea didn't like cam all that much near the end of the game, he was irritating her a lot but her crush on him blinded her. But that doesn't matter too much because she still won, though I thought Makenzies game was better, but yea that's just my personal opinion with all respect to you because you actually made the list, I just watched

Yes! Pretty much agree!

I want to say while I agree with the placement, I think Steve knew his social skills were trash garbage that’s why he’s said since before entering the house if he was ever gonna make it past night/week 1 he needed to attach to somebody and play down any threat level.

So, even when he was talking or even upsetting people they were just like “eh it’s Steve what’s he gonna do whatever” but really he was pretty capable of winning comps if he needed to (won the first veto to save himself for example) and was always thinking about how he was perceived (he wanted to seem like a naive little boy who is a waste of an eviction, and Austin literally started calling him ‘the boy’).

All this to say while I agree his game has flaws I do think he was aware of his flaws going in and throughout. He knew he’s not a very social person and not a person most people naturally like.

ty for saying boogie > will at the start of the video bc it’s not worth watching if you genuinely believe that LMAOO

Chelsie is the GOAT. Taylor ❤

Josh continues to be emotional and a terrible player on The Challenge.

Chelsie 3rd is insane LOL

See i blame angela for the mismanaging chelsie than chelsie mismanaging her. Chelsie had her back throughout the game but angela couldnt take accountability and was always paranoid. Chelsie was always trying to lift that woman's spirit and Angela is being rahrah for girls who stated she shouldnt be there and was called a bully. Chelsie took care of angela during her punishment. Angela didnt get evicted week 3 because of chelsie.

Who invented the floater strategy if it wasn’t Jun 😭😭. Was their floaters on bb2 and 3 was Monica a floater lol like I’m so confused how did she not invent it

So. I KNOW you might get pissed at me…But if you’re up for hearing me out…I think Evel Dick is STILL the worst winner compared to Jag. Mainly due to three factors. 1. The severity of the twists. 2. Social game. 3. Win equity.

1. Evel Dick’s America’s Player twist is way worse than being allowed to re-enter the game. Buybacks/Battlebacks have been around for multiple seasons. It’s more consistent and the players who return can at least control their fate a bit more…Evel Dick really gets lucky that America’s Player cripples Eric and forces him to do moves that actively benefit Dick and weakens his (Dick) opposition.

2. This one is easy. Evel Dick actively went out of his way to torment his cast. He used a 23-year-old woman’s body as a literal ashtray for crying out loud. Jag didn’t do anything nearly as bad as that.

3. Evel Dick loses to EVERYONE in the jury phase EXCEPT Dani, his daughter. That is his ONE winning scenario. A scenario neither would have gotten to had America’s Player not been a thing! That’s why Zach stuck with him and Dani until Final 3. Because he KNOWS he WINS the game if he can win Final HoH. He beats Dick and Dani handily. At least with Jag, by the time he got to the finale, he at least wins against either Bowie Jane or Matt (granted, that was due to Matt’s idiotic mistakes, but still).

Chelsie had one of the most dominant wins ever.
That's final.

Her closet ally, at the peak of alliance control, also became #1 enemy (and then, evicted shortly). She adapted and still maintained true position as bus driver.

There is fundamentally no difference between Jag being saved from eviction and anyone else being saved by a twist. If you’d still place him low bc of that whatever but it’s ridiculous to say that he’s somehow worse than Dick when Dick was not only saved from eviction by a twist but continued to benefit from it more than any other winner

Dr. Will is the best player of all time. Shocking that you would put him in that tier. He is better than Dan (who they rigged the game for in BB10) and Derrick. I agree with Derrick and Andy being top tier players. But Dan is not and Will is top tier.

I had the feeds for BB2. Will completely dominated his season and from a strategy standpoint and he did it with no blueprint as to how to play and with virtually no allies. He was able to correct mistakes in his own game and beat and manipulate his passive allies in the end who wanted to tear him apart. He masterfully manipulated the outcome of every comp so that he could play for one more week, and he did that repeatably. He played one of the most influential games in Big Brother history, so much so that Dan wanted to play like Will and even copied Will even down to the fucking swim trunks he wore in BB10.

It's completely revisionist history to say he's overrated like some are saying here. The guy practically invented how the game should be played.

You know what? I'm sorry to be that person, but after you made such a big deal about Jag being the worst winner due to be voted out, I think it's only fair to point out that Taylor was in a similar situation with her being saved due to the backstage boss twist cancelling her eviction. Taylor got put up at the veto meeting, and she wasn't able to get the votes to stay in the game by Thursday night. Normally, this would have been GG for Taylor.

I'm not saying Jag was a good winner, by any means. His game still had plenty of other flaws, beyond him being saved. However, if you are going to automatically put him at the bottom of the list, I think you should have compared and contrasted his game with Taylor's, since you clearly put Taylor much higher up than Jag due to her social game.

Nicole should’ve won bb2!

I don’t think Jackson’s game is poor yes I agree he has very bad social play at most points but strategically I really think Jackson picks it up towards the end the Tommy move is one of the best moves Jackson did in big brother history we also have the act he was able to stay over Jack where there were people way closer to Jack then Jackson yet they kept Jackson there’s some merit to his game but I think saying he has a poor game is not a great take

For bb11, Michelle won the next hoh, so assuming Russel goes, Michelle puts up Natalie and Jesse and it’s a battle between the two sides

I literally do not understand why I find it so funny and beautiful when you call Evil Dick “Richard Donato”. Like it’s just so perfect because of much his nickname I guess comes from his interesting personality, and the fact that you just call him Richard is just perfect lol. Also love the vid!!✨

I’ve said the same thing about Jag, the guy was literally evicted. Period.

Love your takes! This is probably the most rational ranking I’ve ever seen

Such a well-crafted video! Love my bbb!

This is an incredible list! The only thing I'd change is putting Taylor a bit higher, but I completely understand your reasoning for her placement! I'm also always happy to see people place Andy's game at #1 because it's where he belongs 😤❤️

was the 50% diversity quota really needed in BB its false that black/poc's houseguest were being evicted 1st or 2nd before the 50% change was put in the game

a lot the winners pre BB22 would've been out pre-jury aka taylor,jag,xavier,chelsie when white houseguest weren't not afraid to put the up and evict them poc's

chelsie is a little better than jag she only won because makensy had no desire to win the game

jag is a bottom tier winner i don't count jag as a winner but he won so i have to acknowledge him as a winner reluctantly

The women dominating the likability list is a W such iconic queens

My mother chelsie getting the creddit sge deserves

I know it mustve been hard seeing queen rachel in the bottom tiel with those bums lol

THANK YOU for ranking Jag the place you did. I'm not sure why people can defend his game. He's the epitome of a bad player; got evicted, saved by a twist, needed to win competitions to get to the end, and took the person who had more win equity to the final 2 because of "loyalty"...

I guess the flaw with Chelsies game is that lots of the things she does are unintentional. She does make the right decision and dominate the game but not really because she means too I think she gets very lucky, for example the Joseph boot was the right move for her but it was literally an accident. She also didn’t do much to convince Leah not to nominate her just got lucky through her connection through Makensy. But those are my nitpicks she’s definitely top 5 just not perfect

On the topic of Adam, since i watched BB9 for the first time earlier this year:
His game felt very sloppy (his very obvious flip-flopping to please every player in the game simultaneously and most of all risking keeping James the comp beast on the opposing side of the house in the game), he wasn't the most likeable person in the house by any means (that would probably be Sharon) and his start especially left a lot to be desired (hadn't it been for Jacob being dumb as rocks, he and Sheila would've been first out definitely).
However he consistently paid attention to doing damage control and ensure his good standing with remaining players in the game as well as those freshly evicted (not nominating James initially, giving Sheila a cash price to improve her opinion of him and telling Natalie that he voted to keep her). He also tried to keep blood off his hands as good as he could and shove the blame onto someone else, screwing over Ryan in particular (throwing Ryan under the bus during Natalie's eviction, having Ryan be the one to take Sheila's cash price, having Ryan be the one to evict Sheila).

Also his awareness of Sharon as a social threat in the game and his efforts to keep his relationships with others at least somewhat solid and mostly free of resentment to me proves that he at least had his head in the game and knew what he was doing.

(Still agree eith the ranking, but it ultimately worked out for him due to BB9's nature)

well informed and fckble

Personally I think Dan is the best winner. Also for him to come back in 14 as a villain was entertaining and just masterful game play. He should have won 14 as well but I still think Ian was a worthy winner, but still what a robbery all because of a bitter jury

I pretty much on board with both your list. I would put Dr.Will in the Master category since he is the one that basically was a trailblazer/pioneer on how the game of Big Brother should be played (Basically the creator of the game) even though most parts of his game is outdated.

In Regards to Derrick, he is a bit overrated but I would keep him in the master category, Andy I would knock down a peg or 2. He is Vastly overrated and benefited heavily from BB15 cast "drama" that made that season the "Black Sheep" seeing that they did not bring him back for B Stars/C stars I mean Allstars 2 BB22. Speaking of BB22 Cody had pregame alliance on his 2nd go around so I would put him in the solid category not master.

For winners my top 5 IN ORDER are

1 Chelsie
2 Dan
3 Dr Will
4 Derrick
5 Maggie


For all-time players my top 5 IN ORDER are

1 Chelsie BB26
2 Vanessa BB17
3 Dan BB10 & BB14
4 Derrick BB16
5 Tyler BB20

Yup as of 2024 Chelsie is the GOAT!

A couple thoughts I have:

1) I think Lisa is very similar to Jordan: very likable, very consistent, but little to no strategic acumen. At the very least, I would put her at the bottom of solid game, and more realistic need some improvement.

2) Xavier was greatly benefited by the social climate surrounding BB23. Xavier benefited the most from the cookout despite the likes of Hannah, Tiffany, and Kyland doing more to benefit the Cookout, and at many points in the season Xavier was targeted but was saved because of the greater vision of the cookout. Definitely more flawed than given credit.

Omg I didn’t know that you’re Emma Robert’s!?

Will: Neutral Evil
Lisa: Chaotic Good
Jun: Neutral Evil
Drew: True Neutral
Maggie: Lawful Evil
Boogie: Neutral Evil
Dick: Chaotic Evil
Adam: True Neutral
Dan: Chaotic Neutral
Jordan: Lawful Good
Hayden: Neutral Good
Rachel: True Neutral
Ian: Neutral Good
Andy: Chaotic Neutral
Derrick: True Neutral
Steve: Neutral Good
Nicole: True Neutral
Josh: Chaotic Evil
Kaycee: Lawful Good
Michie: Neutral Evil
Cody: Neutral Good
Xavier: Lawful Neutral
Taylor: Neutral Good
Jag: Chaotic Good
Chelsie: True Neutral

Just to say abt chelsies game- in jankie world she did nothing all she did was fight with cam mj was the one putting in all the work so they would be nominated - BBB said that Chelsie skirted it so she would be nominated but I disagree- You know how u said she that mike was to prideful that’s how I see Chelsie she knew that she nominated Quinn Leah’s showmance so she didn’t want to talk to her

Let me know when you find out what Ollie's last name is

Let me know when you find oht what Ollie's last name is

They need to make a teen big brother season and I will win cuz I can wait anymore years

25. Dick
24. Josh
23. Rachel
22. Jordan
21. Jag
20. Jackson
19. Adam
18. Ian
17. Mike
16. Kaycee
15. Lisa
14. Steve
13. Drew
12. Taylor
11. Hayden
10. Xavior
9. Nicole
8. Maggie
7. Will
6. Jun
5. Cody
4. Andy
3. Derrick
2. Chelsea
1. Dan

I also love Rachel, but the f act that she had 3 votes locked in the jury (Jeff, Jordan, and Brendan), all previous relationships from outside the house, shows that even her winning vote was not impressive.

Taylor didn’t need to have michael bring her to the end because she literally had monte do it. So i don’t see how that’s a bad move. Taylor also literally put in hella work to
make sure Monte and Turner was very good with her to the point it made britney upset. You can knock her for the britney flip but She definitely earned her position with Monte and Turner. Raise my girl up she’s way too low.