Haley Scarnato - Elimination

Of course she can sing, she made it to the top 8, what kind of comment is that?

Besides, this was THE best elimination performance I have ever heard on AI. She was spirited and put everything she had into it.

Don't be jealous Brianna, not everyone can look great.

Not true, I voted for her because of her voice. She was something different, not a diva. I liked it.

The only time she sounded good was in her elimination....

HAHA NO she aint a slut and y do canada get to see american idol why cant we see canadian idol not fair!!!!!

I liked Haley, but I wasn't heartbroken when she got eliminated. I knew that she was one of the weakest contestants remaining, and it was just her time to go. Her appeal to me was that she just seemed so sweet and it looked like she really loved singing. I felt bad that she missed Martina McBride by one week though, since she said in her interview on the American Idol website that that was the guest mentor she was most looking forward to.

I liked Haley but Phil was my favorite so I'm happy he stayed that night

She sang better.

I like this girl. Maybe voice not so strong, but not forgetable like Leona Lewis` voice from X-Factor haha

to Brianna and others who post mean comments you need to think about other people's feelings before you post comments like that. how do you think Haley would feel if she read that? If you're gooing to critisize (sp)? please do it nicely. No need to spread negativity.

Thank you so much! I always try to stick up for people Mean people really upset me because I used to be picked on when I was younger so I make it a point to be nice to everyone Have a good day!

hey brianna BE NICE!

I agree 100% with authorgirl86. Think about the person first before you say something mean.

brianna stop being mean! Haley was the best! And she sings GOOD!

And just to let everyone know Haley is in the recording studio right now.

thank you

Your Welcome!

STOP PICKING ON HALEY!

I was so glad when she got voted off, because she relly didn't have much talent to sing to be begin with. I'm from San Antonio, and even everyone I knew were hoping, she got the boot. By the way...if she is in the recording studio right now, thank god that there is actually technology that can enhance her voice to make her sound decent. Cuz she don't have much of a voice.

Maybe she should do a performance with Gwen Stefani and Amerie, the 2 other singers who I think have the hottest legs!

she sucks? not! listen to her sing the national anthem- good

I HATED Phil that season! He wouldn't go away!!! D<

Just shut your rotten mouth jerk!!!! She's the best and you know it!!! So there!!

Her voice was beautiful!!! Unlike yours!!!!

Yeah and she just missed that week. Sucks.

haley is awesome...she's clearly having fun every time she sings...don't hate!

No wonder she got eliminated. Terrible singing. ugh

I that Sharon Osbourne at 2:44?!

Is that Sharon Osbourne at 2:44?!

They were right that her song choice was incorrect, HOWEVER, in my opinion she has a good pure voice, but she doesn't know how to use it properly selecting the right songs.