The Perplexing Disappearance of Judge Joseph F. Crater

Make sure to leave your questions for our Post Mortem episode down below!

This stinks of a mob hit imo. The Tammany hall connection sells it for me. Burying him under the boardwalk is also very believable

Coming from someone who is well versed in the world of mafioso AKA the five families or just the mafia as the plebians call it. I bet they got him on the payroll or tried to. Either he went with it and messed up or shot it down and threatened said mob they could make him dissappear in many ways. Maybe he got the old cement shoes, like Luca Brasi from the GodF hes swimming with the fish now

The most missingest.. what about Jimmy Haffa

christina whittaker is the most missingest woman in america.

I miss this content

Shane's highlights make him look like Marcy Darcy 😂

He was up to no good, no telling what happened.

Shane doesn't have anxiety thats exactly what id think if I didn't hear from a friend in a week

So much self hate from Shane. Many would consider him a dapper rich white guy. 😂

And here's the thing he was embezzling money and then he took off because he was getting close to maybe getting caught

It's so funny that's exactly what I was thinking how many bodies are they finding in hotels my goodness lol

Bowtie are Cool 🎀

Y’all should do some more non-homophobic true crime stories.

It's cringe when they speak in between

The commentary is terrible..

Wrong....jimmy hoffa is the most missingest man in the usa......both hoffa and crater are sleeping with the fishes in them concrete boots.

I dress like a ice cream man 😂

Oh no Mr. Bill 💸

The poor wife... That ending was horrible.. I hope she's in a happy place now...

Just for everyone's benefit,
there is another video here
about this missing judge that
is only ten minutes long,
compared to 23 minutes here.
The bonus is you just get the
story WITHOUT the annoying
dialog of these two dimwits
who mistakenly think they
are funny ..... You're welcome.

As a doctor who fan I am not mad, DISSAPOINED

He looks just like a velociraptor i’m sorry

I'd say Jimmy Hoffa is the missingest man in American history, no one has been looked for so vigorously for so long with so little found. Obviously we probably have a pretty good idea of what happened, but we can't really ever prove it. My opinion though, I'm sure it's debatable.

Let be fr tho
Bow ties are cool

Shane: I can’t wait for this guy to go missing, I don’t like him.

Idk why that sentence is so funny to me.

He def was paying someone off and disappeared cuz someone needed him out the way

i guess it'll forever be... *a mystery*

Hmmm….corrupt democrats? Ya don’t say?

Shane, when isaulting bowties you described my exact reason for wearing bow ties all throughout elemetary

It is me Wagner(russian accent)

He didn't blow it! The jews are doing way better than the whites.

Shane dressed like a clown won't wear a bow tie meanwhile he got one of those flower in the buttonhole things...

Shane talking about Doctor who is everything to me

Someone should ask Michael Franzese. Maybe he has some insights for this case

Idk i dont think this makes him any more missing than other missing persons

Shane’s shirt is giving Whataburger

I do not know why, but I have watched this episode like 10 times, which is only slightly less than all other True Crime episodes, and not a single time have I remembered what happens or fully grasped the story 😂 JUST THIS ONE. Is it just me??

I don't know if I buy him running away to start a new life and using the money he withdrew from the bank to do it just because $5150 is a very specific number. If it was an even $5000 or something similar, it would make more sense, but withdrawing $5150 sounds more like maybe he was paying someone off. Maybe he was involved with selling/buying judgeships, and someone found out? Or if he was trying to cover up his affairs.

this channel died when these two left fr went from millions of views to barely scraping 50k

I click on this to learn something about the case, I found it intriguing. But all I got was these two chodes going on about whether he was a snazzy dresser or not! Tell the story and inform people and leave your opinions in your face. Cuz believe me nobody gives two ships would either one of you think about the subject just tell the f**** story!

He took a bit over $5grand which would allow him to live ok on that. That wld get him started in new home or apt plus car depending on where he ended up then he just provides new name and DONE! New life, new job, new wife

These missing persons cases from the 1930s are so whack bruh. All it takes is the mob to get someone and pay some hush money to the cops to get away with it

Shane is wearing a Whataburger shirt.