Комментарии:
in 1 minute and 28 seconds, without saying a single word, you have explained how PID tuning works better than any other article or video I have ever seen
ОтветитьYou explained PID better than the uni course i attended, nice
ОтветитьI just love how without words, all of us just got intuitive understanding of what PID does and how it "feels" what parameters do.
ОтветитьThe missile knows where it is because it knows where it isn’t. By subtracting where it is from where it will be…
ОтветитьI sir salute you. Nothing else has ever made this much sense. Thank you so much for this beautiful demonstration
ОтветитьGENIUS video !!!!
ОтветитьCan you show us how to make this?
Ответитьzomg, thank you for this
Ответитьsomeone explain this in a way so that a 13 year old kid can understand it.
ОтветитьIs it possible that this could happen: Those who already understand it find it even more intuitive and easy to comprehend. Those who didn't understand it in the first place still don't understand. I belong to the former group.
ОтветитьI want oneeeee
ОтветитьI play a game "Stormworks", I always fail to setup my PID, this explained better than anything. Thanks!
ОтветитьNice demo.
Ответить🙏THANK U VERY MUCH
ОтветитьThanks!
ОтветитьNice demonstration! gives another, more practical alternative perspective other than those transient response graphs
ОтветитьIdk,im just trying to tune my fpv quad pid
ОтветитьExplanation for those who have questions: The upper right hand switch controls the system power supply. The lower left side switch sets all the potentiometers to zero (down) or enabled (up). The upper pulley and pointer are mounted on a motor. The motor drives the lower pulley through the drive belt, which turns the position potentiometer as the system measured variable.
The left side potentiometer is the system position setpoint. The pointer, and the position potentiometer attempt to follow the position of the set point potentiometer. When the enable switch is down, the set point, position, and PID potentiometers are all set to zero. The effects of P, I and D can be observed by adjusting their respective control potentiometers. Most feedback control systems are tuned for stability using different settings of P, P and I, P and D, or all three. There are also I controllers but are not very common.
Entire day I have been reading papers and watching various videos and this simple video with no words explained it much better than all of them, amazingly simple! Thank you!
ОтветитьI want to reproduce thi pid demo for my final school exam, coud someine help me with a little tutorial?
ОтветитьI have seen P, PI, PD, and PID control system
They always have P on it
What will happen if a control system doesn't have Proportional?
Thank you so much :)
ОтветитьHello
May I have the circuit behind the panel?
Thank you
Where can I buy one of these? Ultimate fidget toy.
Ответить👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
ОтветитьWhat would limits be?
ОтветитьThis is great for visual learner like me!!
Ответитьbeing flying quadcopter and try understand quad for 8 years and still unsure... you just brighten my mind in 1 min
ОтветитьWho watching trying to find out how to use there pod setting for holley lol
ОтветитьAmazing demonstration of a PID controller !
ОтветитьNice video. But speak something. Like what is the set point , right side or left side. Mark set point with a line. Explain all. Also, not cleared that which direction is gain increased. Or decreased. Though nice effort.
ОтветитьSo good - thanks!
ОтветитьGod bless you!
ОтветитьParfait...Merci
ОтветитьThank you so much !!! I understand well know!!! (16yo!😁)
ОтветитьVery good, thank you
Ответитьthank you very much!
ОтветитьThe switch is up the pointer goes to the right. But can it point to the left instead when the switch is up? In other words can it be flipped 180deg?
ОтветитьBest explanation 🔥🔥🔥🔥.
Ответитьthank you
ОтветитьIm gonna build my sons some cool toys using these. Fascinating stuff
ОтветитьThis is great, been trying tune in my drones, built 4, the fly smooth as silk.. wow... ty.
ОтветитьThat's a great demonstration!
ОтветитьThere needs to be a digital version of this device, I want to try it myself!
ОтветитьThis is truly very genius. All you need to know, almost, about PID operation in this very short video.
Ответитьso this is what was happening when i tried to make a motor stop at a specific spot using a potentiometer to know were it was, it just keept moving back and fort dodging the spot it had to be.
i just increased the range, and dint give it much tought, but now i see there was a better way to deal with it.
anyone tried modifying this using only a RC servo motor?
ОтветитьI'm electric engineer and pass control lesson, include PID theory. But didn't understand as good as this video show.
ОтветитьMARVELLOUS
👍👍👍
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Ответить