Комментарии:
Allah guides whom He wills. Those He leaves to stray, they are the losers, they are the companions of the hell fire.
ОтветитьMuhammad is not the author of the qur'an. Allah, God The Almighty is the author of the qur'an.
ОтветитьIt's a choice in today's world to be ignorant,with all the knowledge that the internet gives us other avenues to go down and he can't find a one.
I feel SORRY for this man. My 5 yr old son could have researched better. This is sad. What about Islamic references,and those historian like cheik ana Diop, Hykal, so many more. No, no what sincere seekers of knowledge want to know is WHERE IN HISTORY DID WE LOSE THE 7th TO 14th century in which this way of life ( Islam is not a religion,it's a way of life) brought knowledge to a world that was called THE DARK AGES. How in the heck did we come out of the dark ages come on now Definitely not Christianity ( nothing against Christianity) nor Jewish r any other religion. It was ISLAM When everyone else was in total ignorance Europe was enjoying ignorance, the learn,men of knowledge was suppressed or kill. They said being dirty was next to God,this was the Catholic Church,an other parts of the world was in darkness. This history it was ISLAM that lite to the world and no one ,.no one can say anything different. A thousand yrs this way of life gave knowledge, morals, creativity, the right worship of the ONE ALLAH(had no son)he has no consorts. And to end this the west as yet to Thank Islam for it's contribution to the Internet why? Because if it was not for Arabic numbers that we use today 123456789 that O and that 1 made possible the world wide web. Computers could be possible if it was relying on roman numerals. Your computer runs on 1and 0s. If you don't give credit to this way of life now I promise u inshallah (if Allah will)
You will later.
Idiot,the prophet had offsprings ,companions ,Sira nad Hadith literature..there are inscriptions and verses of Quran on parchments,stones ..what could be greatest proof than his shrine is also the re in medina,the cemetery of bai where his family members and companions rest,his letters to different rulers and covenant with Christian’s well preserved ..his relics in Istanbul museum..how idiot is this guy,just narrating his vain thinking 😅..idiot
Ответить😂 even historical facts are denied now
ОтветитьThe stories in wich those bedoins believe, about bearing the daughters alive before islam, are simply not true. They are just beliefs (told by Mohamed in Hadeets) but not based on any facts. And here is why . Khadija was the wife of the prophet BEFORE islam. She was a powerfull woman , she had her own bussiness and Mohamed was one of her own employes. All thisBEFORE islam. So women could get a high status before islam. In some arab tribes the women were also leaders before islam ! If the women were seen so worthless as the parents would beared the girls alive , the women couldnt never get any high status as Khadija got or become leaders of the tribes ( wich by the way , Mohamed killed some of them as he has seen them as a threaths to his own power). After Mohamed imposed islam , women lost many right they had before ,their right to own bussiness, their right to become leaders. They became simply the property of men. They couldnt even go out without a male guardian. This practice(male guardian for women ) is even extended today in islamic countries.
ОтветитьTHERE ARE MANY MUSLIMS HISTORIANS. WHAT SO HARD?
Ответитьit's rather untold lie about islam
ОтветитьWas Muhammad pedophile?
ОтветитьAfter reading the comments i dnt think i need to say anything ... but ill just say that this video is a product of narrow minded research it will convince narrow minded people but i see the objective here 😂
ОтветитьInteresting documentary well put together but it fails to mention how silly, fake, ripped off, dumb, absolute sex cult that islam is. Contradictions, Historical inaccurte all around just made up and ridiculous. Anyone that disagrees is just in the cultural of middle East culture it's hard to go against what you grew up with and are surrounded by.
ОтветитьThis man is building on incorrect information, and what is strange is that he did not meet any Saudi or Jordanian Muslim cleric, for example, and ask him about his doubts? Islam is a religion believed by 2 billion people and in the heart of civilization, not a remote jungle religion!
ОтветитьIslam is the only religion and the final from God,, and the Quran is the final testament for all universes,, those who will believe will be haven , those no will be fire 🔥 permanently ❤❤💫💫💫✊✊
ОтветитьShortly after this documentary was released - that eminent scholar Patricia Croner - died. Rest in Peace Patricia Croner (1945~2015) ♥ ✝❤
ОтветитьGreat movie but it’s all about one man’s perception of Islam forming out of an Empire and his lack of finding evidence to prove otherwise….and refusing to use any oral accounts to disprove his perceived idea
ОтветитьModern west progressing because it believes in Science and Middle East Asian societies are backward because they believe in faith and fairy tales.
Ответитьi wish this video translate on indonesia language and not only france
ОтветитьHow blind you truly are to claim there's no evidence of Islam, I hope those watching this are not as ignorant as the presenter's are, do your own basic research on islamic history and you would find the truth for yourself.
ОтветитьThe documentary appears quite constrained, particularly concerning the sources utilized to substantiate the presented information. As a historian striving for objectivity and seeking to convey an accurate representation of reality, it's essential to incorporate a diverse range of references, including those emanating from local and Muslim communities. By synthesizing information from a comprehensive array of sources, you are more likely to approximate a true depiction of events. However, by examining the issue from a singular perspective as you have, your final conclusion seems somewhat restricted and potentially subjective.
Ответитьthis isn't tom holland... what the fuck is this
ОтветитьSuch stupidy.. companian of prophet been noting his story since beginning. Oh white people..
ОтветитьSharia was made up by Muhammud, and was never part of authentic Islam which existed for 700 million years on other planets
ОтветитьHere is a clear evidence that the director of this video is not a Islam friendly. The intention behind this documentary is to fool those Muslims with a weak faith. Now the narrator is talking about evidences of Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him , he ask why there’s not a coin dating from his time, why is there not a scripture with the name of Muhammad? Interesting …. That’s how non Muslims try to confuse the weak Muslims. We do have a lot of evidences that prophet Muhammad peace be upon him was real and preaches Islam. But my question for those Jews and Christians people who are always looking for evidences or archeological evidences about Islam. Do you guys have any evidences that Prophet Moses and Jesus ever existed? Because there’s none and you guys still believing on them right? The oldest manuscripts ever found that confirms the Bible are the Dead Sea scrolls but wait a minute…. Those scrolls were taking to a laboratory and the carbon test results showed that those manuscripts are dated 1000 + years after the dead of prophet Moses and 100+ years after prophet Jesus 😮 meaning the one or the ones who wrote those manuscripts never met neither Moses or Jesus. So how legit those manuscripts are? Or maybe those manuscripts are a copy and paste from the pagan Catholic Roman church? And if you guys claim that those manuscripts are from GOD and they’re authentic then why the Jews and the Church just accepted few of them and rejected the others books like The Book of Enoch? Mmmm so many questions but not so many answers. In the other side the oldest Quranic scriptures ever found is named ( The Birmingham Qurān ) and the laboratory carbon test dated those scriptures from the time of Prophet Muhammad meaning whoever wrote those Quranic verses met prophet Muhammad and heard him reciting those verses. They decided to bring a Muslim Imam ( preacher ) to confirm if the Birmingham Qurān has the same verses like the Qurān Muslims uses nowadays in their daily lives and surprise surprise was confirmed that they’re the same letter by letter words by words. So that leads to confirm what Allāh promises in the Qurān that he will preserve and protect The Qurān himself has been fulfilled. So instead of you guys wasting money on documentaries trying to confuse weak Muslims , you better question your books and biblical story because saying that the modern Bible are evidences that are from GOD make non sense when the dead sea scrolls dated from 1000+ after Moses and 100+ years after Jesus . And let’s not talk about the New Testament because that’s another fairytale story that Jesus never preached to his people or the children of Israel. Saying so all I have to say is Assalamu Alaykom .
ОтветитьYou will be a Muslim after this project
ОтветитьPower,Rich,Sex is mission human like prophet but the follower trust the truth from representing the nation of jews and protect their life we are truth but protecting the liars because don’t know what the agenda..truth from god not happen until today but god will open their eyes mind hearing what’s the truthful is it..waiting Messiah not a Mahdi not a Jesus but the unknown messiah ..thanks giving to nation of Jews balanced the world law from the followers eviltruth to conquer the world
The only one god and god never haven’t or command the slave ,messenger,son of god whatever it’s called but god is himself guide the human being without helping from human from past and until today
This is trash...he totally ignore the facts...
ОтветитьJust putting this out there first testiment, king james, dead sea scrools , book of Enoch, how many books , quran , vatican liberty , black magic , there is one god , we all all one , peace love and light! How far down the ice burg do you want to go?
ОтветитьGreat presentation. I lived in Abqaiq, Saudi Arabia, working in the oil industry from 1978 to late 1981. I was in a compound where only supervisory Saudis lived among us, with Americans, British and a few of us Canadians.. I have read the entire Quran given me as a gift. I keep it with my Bibles, Catholic and Protestant. While living there I learned to read, write and speak Arabic although my reading was at a grade school level. Beyond my fellow Saudi workers and other X patriots with whom I worked, I gained a good relationship with a Muslim Mutawa, Hadi Sala, who was also an oil works Superintendent making him powerful. To me the competition between Rome and Constantinople caused the Prophet Mohammed to 'do his own thing' if I may use such an expression.
ОтветитьIt’s just his voice
ОтветитьBeware of Islam and Islamists…Islam is the combination of Ignorants and extremists…They are dangerous to Human Race…
ОтветитьThere was a German archeologist who found a book that resembled the Koran in stories and writing - not exactly the same -- but it was found in Yemen. It was dated to 300 years before Mohammed.
ОтветитьEarly Mosques had people pray towards Jerusalem, not Mecca.
ОтветитьTom Holland! Your heart is blind as well as your mind. :)
ОтветитьIn my heart I wanted to believe it
But my head wouldn't let me"
A summary of my journey out of Islam.
felt very biased
ОтветитьFull of shit
ОтветитьThe best proof of the prophecy of Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him, is your report, where the Prophet Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him, said the hadith 1400 years ago when there were a few Muslims with him.
Imam Ahmad recorded from Tamim Ad-Dari that he said, "I heard the Messenger of Allah saying, This matter (Islam) will keep spreading as far as the night and day reach, until Allah will not leave a house made of mud or hair, but will make this religion enter it, while bringing might to a mighty person (a Muslim) and humiliation to a disgraced person (who rejects Islam). Might with which Allah elevates Islam (and its people) and disgrace with which Allah humiliates disbelief (and its people). Tamim Ad-Dari, who was a Christian before Islam used to say, "I have come to know the meaning of this Hadith in my own people. Those who became Muslims among them acquired goodness, honor and might. Disgrace, humiliation and Jizyah befell those who remained disbelievers.''
Jealousy christians always critcise because their religion is FAKE
🤭👎🤣
Peter in an alternate universe. Joking aside, amazing video
ОтветитьAbsolutely nonsense movie
ОтветитьRead History of the Arabs by Paul Hitti. The Quran itself is a reference to history. Stories? 😂 Go thru time travel for "evidence"
ОтветитьGeezus! Everybody who can read a book can know how Arabs became Muslim. Do you have eyes? Can you read? Something is wrong with you. The oral tradition was witnessed by thousands and transmitted by thousands even down to this very day, without a break in the chain, those traditions are reported. Christianity does not have this nor does Judaism. Your "documentary is riddled with lies, deception, and innuendo. I pray you wake up before you wake up.
ОтветитьPatricia is a giant among Islamic revisionists
ОтветитьTom, you're the bes!
ОтветитьThe narrative in Islam has a lot of holes. Of course all narratives sometimes have but Islam just have too many. For example they can't link mohammad to Ismail and even they can Islamic history says Ismail can't proof that he was the son from Allah. Similarly the Mecca is a secret well kept too.
ОтветитьMay be the black hole exists in your head and the only way to light it is to discard the christian idea that profets must be worshiped along with the obvious z!on!st misleading stories...
ОтветитьA documentary by a self desctobed unbeliever is merely propaganda
ОтветитьIsmael/Esau =
Arab/Jew alliance