Whitepine Theory: The Killer From The Darkness

what type of Whitepine video? i tryna search minecraft story but it keep show me minecraft story mode i just wanna watch ppl make minecraft story like this

Pls change your avatar you look like dream

Wait, I think I have something, I’ve seen a comment about her being like a half vampire, and having vampires.

I can imagine, because of the ‘trauma’ or something.. If not someone left her stunned,
Since they didn’t talk about Mrs. Hemlock, what if Mrs. Hemlock was still alive? Faked her death to gather prey for the house/mansion, what if Mrs. Hemlock IS a vampire?

And for Ivory, since there are theories about her being a half-vampire, I can imagine that Ivory was grown in a full-vampire family, what if she ran away? Not getting any stuff in hopes they won't find her, but they followed her, or at least someone followed her. As she looked in the forest, maybe they lived in a forest looking just like that.. Or even THAT forest..?

And about how Mr. Pierce / Clownpierce said: “Ivy, correct?” - There is something called Poison Ivy, Ivory might’ve been named Ivy, but then changed it to ‘Ivory’ to not bring attention to her past, and her family finding her. She played the piano, I can imagine she was taught how to play the piano by someone before she ran away, maybe her grandparents, and if it was in the past, they might be dead by now, or killed by Ivory’s parents.

And about ‘The Hunt’ Zam said, what if they were acquainted with the parents, and when they found out Ivory was there, they had to get her.

the "HELP" in the letter is some game theory shit XD

What if the monster is a werewolf type monster. And it seemingly killed the mother, they left the mother, mother turns into another monster. Mother is angry that they kept her alone and killed mr cat. Or confused about her new powers and accidentally killed mr cat. And the "hunt" often to see the mother.

Soem other comment mentioned a figure leaving the blank shot before the murder, and a reply thought maybe tehy let the monster in, but why? maybe because they had let in the mother.

btw i think the murdurer has to know the house and people's scedule well enough to escape that quickly and avoid so much people, how else did they escape the crime scene and have the body discovered later?

I bet you 50 bucks it was the guy that said "Im...just a buttler"

the thing is that the day before the saidd thatt they will go hunting ....so besiclly the owners werent home....plus missy was one of the main servants... thats why see one the one that whent to open the fire is the oldest room....maybe that made her a target?...

Martin Frank Robinson Steven Jackson Thomas

Robinson Patricia Hall Gary Walker Daniel

not sure if this has been picked up on but before the main scream theres a really faint scream you can hear a few seconds before
but im not sure if thats just me tweaking, maybe the first was a scream from mister upon seeing the monster and a second upon getting attacked; noticing its coming in the same direction, not too sure tho

ooooo, good video

the forest is definitely involved. pyroscythe was staring into it before he talked to mysti. i actually think her walking into his room is one of the reasons she died. also what in the universe is a hunt? i feel like it being a not-creepy rich person guns and forests wildlife hunt doesn't fit right.

also i feel like calling them hemlockes is a bit on the nose... a twist might be coming from that direction. honestly the 'ivy, not ivory' scene made me wonder.

the servants definitely know a lot that ivory doesn't...

The bitemark is very Iconic. It's too obvious what kills everyone here.
The Pinus monticola Is very deadly and a good hunter. Those Monsters can eat an entire moose a day! They are very scary and you should not cross their way, but if you do, cover yourself with gravy. It won't stop them from eating you but at least you're not gonna taste terrible either.

my personal theory is that she, ivory, was in a war of some sort or at least a setting where she had to be disciplined and tough enough to do something until it was completed like Violet in Violet Evergarden. There are a LOT of parallels between Ivory and Violet some of those being: they both struggle with emotions they don't understand, they're an orphan with ambiguous histories, they're socially inept, and they are exceptionally good at working until something is completed without being exhausted afterward.

My theory is that there is/was a spirit in the piano and then when Ivory played the piano it released the spirit therefore started hunting and killing people. (I don’t have much information on this BUT THE SERIES IS REALLY GOOD)

Having watched episode two I just realized it might be the person in the forest who went there after the murder. This theory is for the scenes of the forest and staircase.

The murderer could have used a gun but that is unlikely cuz like everybody would hear the gunshots. Ngl though it could have been done by something like a axe or a hammer

idk i think serapter is the killer

If the monster killed the mom, why would they go hunting?

I feel like it's probable there was no scream from the murder itself. Fast murder, as you said, could catch someone off guard enough to just kill.
As for who did it, probably not a person. Monster? Evil spirit? Who knows.

wait but could the killer have not just moved her body after killing her?

I got this on my recommended and never seen anything about nvnay of this, the video's barely started and I feel like I fell into the deep end of the pool as a kid

in whitepine 2 you can see that the area seraptor and ivory were in during the forest scene doesn't have a visible fence. the fence probably ended near the front which is why I think that was the easiest entry into the manor

another theory in episode 2 of whitepine since the forest is linked with the murder and the only person we see in the forest was divy. so maybe hes a part of this?

I’d like to point out how they shoot some scenes as well, almost as if we are looking from another persons perspective, hiding, unseen or like a cctv cams view. Shots that feel like we are stalking as we watch characters interact with each other and then being left alone to sit in a dull silence.

Maybe it’s just how they shot the scenes, but some really do feel like we are someone watching, staring, intruding almost.

Another theory:
There’s a monster, it’s in the forest for some reason kills Misty, Ivory and Pyro know the monster (Ivory just stared at the body after it was discovered) it comes out for some reason, maybe because they left the forest and it’s taking revenge by unaliving their closest friends!

Some problems that I have with this theory (very long winded responses below):

1. There has been literally no evidence of there being a monster in the story so far. We know that there is definitely something wrong with the woods since people have been going missing in it, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that there’s a beast going and killing people. In regards to Ivory’s fixation with the woods, literally anything could have happened to her during her time out there that could have led her to sustain some kind of trauma explaining this fixation of hers. Though, if there is a monster killing people and ivory did have an encounter with it, then I don’t see why ivory would be so fixated on going back out there. One more thing: if a monster did take a massive bite out of the back of mysticat’s neck like you say, then the detective wouldn’t be questioning human suspects as her potential killers. Not necessarily evidence that there isn’t a monster, more so just the fact that that mark on her neck isn’t a bite mark. In regards to the rest of her wounds, again I’d like to think that the detective and everyone else would be able to distinguish claw marks from stab wounds, so if this was a monster then suspecting humans doesn’t really make sense.

2. It seems unlikely that Mrs hemlock was killed recently. We can intuit this much from the fact that seraptor doesn’t clearly remember that Mrs hemlock used to play the piano in that one brightly colored room from episode 1. If she’d died recently, then not only would the existence of the piano not have been something that he’d have to question since it’s been moved to the basement presumably after her death (moving the piano would have likely been a job for him or the other workers) he’d also likely remember hearing it or at least seeing it as he worked around the house. This seems to imply that the piano has resided in the basement for a while now, meaning that Mrs hemlock has likely been dead for some time. Furthermore, if she had died recently, then given the fact that the butlers/maids’ jobs are to attend to the hemlock family’s needs, you’d think Ivory would be told of her death so that she could better support them emotionally as they’re grieving. Of course, if the butlers/maids haven’t been told of her death like you say, then this wouldn’t be an issue, however given what we know about the piano, it seems more likely that she died a long time ago and it’s old news as opposed to her having died recently and no one knows about it since why would they have moved the piano to the basement if Mrs hemlock is still believed to be alive and enjoys playing it?

3. The hemlock family is clearly hiding something. We can infer this from the HELP letter, since the “help” message itself is clearly only meant to be understood by the hemlock family and whoever it was that wrote it. From a narrative perspective, it would really only makes sense that this is somehow related to the death of mysticat and potentially Mrs hemlock, otherwise there’d be no point in including it in the story from a writing perspective. Going off of that logic, if the secret is that there is a monster killing people and that they’re trying to hide it’s existence from the world, then the help letter arriving right as the monster makes it first kill could make a lot of sense (maybe it escaped from this other party’s control and is targeting the hemlock estate now), but then why would the hemlock family have any interest in staying where they are now after receiving the help letter? Even if they were going to leave the workers to die they’d at least want to protect themselves in some way, however, as far as we know, they haven’t done anything. Also, people have been going missing in the woods for presumably some time now, so unless that letter just happened to take forever getting delivered then the timeframe for this being linked to a monster doesn’t really seem plausible.

I think It’s hard to say what’s really been going on at this point. we haven’t really received any cohesive/conclusive evidence within these first two episodes, instead we’ve had a lot of setup for what’s to come. Given a little more time, I’m sure whitepine will deliver an amazing narrative, but for now we wait…

I think it’s just Mugm or the green version of ivory.

with ep 2 the scene with ivory in the forest confirms my therory that shes the murderer and that shes just trying to hide her murderous pultions dont hate pls its just a theory

Also they saidthat a lot of people went missing on the forest, like why does no one talk about that!?

Interesting take, most people(including me) are thinking it’s a murder mystery story. But this could be nice. Also the H E L P is interesting, I kinda wanna go back and see if there’s any other hidden words, even if they have no meaning.

This is a good theory,but one problem if it's true, the monster gonna look goofy as hell in Minecraft

In the forest when Ivory is strolling in the forest she sees a man and walks as fast as she can from that person. This happened in whitepine 2.

I love the fact there is a Minecraft series, that we can look at the body to see if its stab wounds or bite marks and that be (likley) an intentional detail

Low-key I feel like mistycat was murdered by a chandelier. It would explain the wounds and her body looks like she fell.

I think mysticat just fell down the stairs

i agree with your first point that the stream and its bite marks but what else leaves bite marks a zombie and guess what happened the day before "there is a hunt tmr" and lastly the zombie had no remorse for the dead and lastly zam said your only the new maid because- it was because mys dies because zombie didnt like mys and lastly when they find the body ash says "why dose it matter lalala" i dont remember but that dose implie that mys had drama in the past with family + workers

Personally I agree that @plantlover3741 when saying it could be a vampire and that ivory could be a dampyr.

I watched white pine in vr and it really immerses you into the story

I feel like mysticat was probably running away from something or someone, if it was that fast a struggle might’ve happened before she got the stairs and maybe got pushed or stabbed

Frostbyte Freeman.
Ratio.

I feel like this isn’t the type of story ivory would go for. We have yet to see any reason to believe the supernatural exists in this world, and honestly, it doesn’t feel right. Ivory is the type of person who wouldn’t make such an obvious of a choice for a plot. Especially considering that this isn’t only a piece of creative work, but also evidently a passion of hers.

All I’m saying is that there’s infinitely more potential for creativity than the monster under the bed. And ivory is the type of person who would see that.

This isn't much of a theory, more like my brain just making patterns.

Saw someone theorize pyroscythe is the murderer, and I found it really interesting that Ivory, the person who seemed to care the least about mysti gets framed and then pyro, the person who seemed to care the most about her death would be the actual killer but not be found suspicious.

it feels like the shot where it shows ivory staring at the camera is showing the monsters perspective, that often happens in movies especially through a barred cage/ or fence

if this was really what it was, it would be really ironic
as ivorytv herself has some similarities with this if it was true
raised in a place that she never had a chance to be herself
i explain it badly but yeah

This theory is so wrong it's hard to imagine you actually paid attention to the story, it is evident that the true killer is Ivory, specifically sleeper agent berserk mode Ivory after being awakened from the piano in episode 1.