Section 31 Review: Dark, Joyless and Dreadful

Section 31 Review: Dark, Joyless and Dreadful

The Dave Cullen Show

2 месяца назад

81,503 Просмотров

Ссылки и html тэги не поддерживаются


Комментарии:

@jaywhite8659
@jaywhite8659 - 19.03.2025 00:40

It's gay humor mixed with alittle 🤏 man insults hating! Not Star Trek!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ответить
@Darthdoodoo
@Darthdoodoo - 18.03.2025 07:31

The demoralization continues

Ответить
@tonydanhs2371
@tonydanhs2371 - 07.03.2025 03:33

A month later opinion.
This looked like a pilot episode and less of a movie.
The budget was practically non existent and felt like it was just a 3 location filming.
The acting feeling off didn't seem to be the fault of the actors but the director and time constraints.
If anything I somehow found each actor to have their own charm but rushed and through a non polished script.
The whole San and godsend plot wasn't a bad one but the execution yet again was rushed to the point it didn't had buildup and impact.
And it didn't had the most important thing star trek has for each episode, a lesson to sharpen the mind and teach critical thinking.
But I also feel like this is a gem in the rough, had it been given more time and more refining could easily be its own thing standing on its own feet.
Between this and woketrek I would take this every time.

Ответить
@KManXPressTheU
@KManXPressTheU - 04.03.2025 02:06

Seriously Folks, It's not Nearly as Bad as People are making it to be.
Think about it:
It wasn't the Enterprise... It wasn't Kirk or Picard who saved the Federation....
It was A Garbage Scow,A Crew of Misfits, And A Doll!
Lighten Up, People!

Ответить
@bjsimon802
@bjsimon802 - 04.03.2025 01:56

I will never watch this like the new star wars

Ответить
@bjsimon802
@bjsimon802 - 04.03.2025 01:55

Hollywood purpose is to kill the culture and kill the nation, this is marxism

Ответить
@tobys4197
@tobys4197 - 27.02.2025 18:20

I could only stand 10 minutes of it and then decided to watch DS9.

Ответить
@alexandruandrei418
@alexandruandrei418 - 25.02.2025 22:44

What section 31 is from the star trek franchise!!!????😅😅😅

Ответить
@KaelanSwan
@KaelanSwan - 25.02.2025 03:41

I finally got around to watching this, hard to say if it's worse than lower decks or not as far as damaging the brand.

Ответить
@tomhenry897
@tomhenry897 - 19.02.2025 17:48

Better then a black Dr who

Ответить
@hightower005
@hightower005 - 19.02.2025 13:38

I couldn't stay awake 😴

Ответить
@Jsa460
@Jsa460 - 16.02.2025 04:53

I remember there was a time when I thought Star Trek the Motionless Picture was the worst ST ever had to offer. How naive I was. At least then movie studios learned from their mistakes and course corrected (the next movie was Wrath of Khan which was great). Now they just keep digging deeper somehow expecting they'll hit gold in their backyard pit instead of just more mud.

Ответить
@1aikane
@1aikane - 15.02.2025 11:23

What happened? The lady is hideous. The content is awful. Who is their target audience? Dreadful

Ответить
@hadi96100
@hadi96100 - 13.02.2025 11:39

Too late, I've watched it at 2X the speed, illegally & still demand a refund for time wasted.

Ответить
@lowket
@lowket - 11.02.2025 09:41

Section 31: you can't polish a turd. Empress Sato was an excellent Mirror Universe female villain. This.... more unwatchable crap with the name 'Star Trek' slapped on it.

Ответить
@RickHansbury
@RickHansbury - 10.02.2025 19:36

Don’t you all get it? The studio has been bragging about it for like a year now. The main “protagonist” is the ultimate anti-hero archetype from the Mirror Universe.”
This is Evil Twin Trek right down the line. The woman is the opposite of Picard or Sisko. I liked them, I don’t hate this character: she is insane to me. Her stated motives do not add up to anything but a shallow, one dimensional stereotype characterization. I’m just not interested. 😜🙄

Ответить
@astralwerks4
@astralwerks4 - 10.02.2025 15:28

It was none of those things. It was fun, action oriented and you clearly didn't get the story.

Ответить
@roberthelme8000
@roberthelme8000 - 09.02.2025 16:53

Klutzman must be some world-class politician/ass kisser . He has no idea what Star Trek is yet is able to hang on to his job as overseer of this garbage, DISCO, Short Treks and seasons 1 & 2 of Picard.

Ответить
@acesw6124
@acesw6124 - 09.02.2025 04:12

have watched a trailer got weorded out thats not Section 31 too bright too much going on wrong musoc etc...


The trailer should have been the voice of Georgiou saying something like Personal Log Stardate .... End Log Security Log Code 31 -Lambda .... Just when I thought of .... Log end Hand places down a communicator to pick up a S31 Black communicator and the whole scene should only show the room shes in her silhouette but never her face maybe a drink shes having basically in the shadows...
Enterprise S31 with Reed and his former commanding officer makes sense since at that time Starfleet was having a more human military +Science/exploration vibe going on until the federation is founded....

Ответить
@worfrozhenko4032
@worfrozhenko4032 - 09.02.2025 00:14

AI writing?

Ответить
@josephmartin7381
@josephmartin7381 - 07.02.2025 22:30

I was hoping this would be the end of bad trek, then I remembered that there's another season of Strange New Worlds... 🤢🤮

Ответить
@deaks25
@deaks25 - 07.02.2025 22:04

The fact that no-one seems to like it, be it New Trek or Classic Trek fans, probably tells you that this was made simply because Michelle Yeoh's character was popular for a while.
The film seems to achieve one thing: Star Trek V and Nemesis are no longer the worst Star Trek films, and from the sounds of it, Section 31 has taken the dubious crown very easily...

The sad thing is, a Section 31 film could have been great. Borrow from the groundwork that DS9 laid and the Operative in Serenity; a "I'm a monster but I'm doing the necessary things, creating a perfect world" ideology and get the setting right, perhaps even in the DS9, Dominion War era and it could have been incredible. All the ingredients were there but someone seems to have done their utmost to f**k it up as hard as possible.

What we got feels like a cynical attempt to earn a quick payday, which has backfired stupendously. Even Yeoh's reputation seems to have taken a hit.

Ответить
@danieljames9322
@danieljames9322 - 07.02.2025 12:19

You're absolutely 100% wrong. You're a Star Trek snob. It was great.

Ответить
@JohnMinehan-f4y
@JohnMinehan-f4y - 06.02.2025 00:44

Something like this could be interesting, if it were played like DS-9's in Ihe Pale Moonlight, with a Federation Midgrade Officer having to adjust her/his ethical expectations . . . but that would not have been very original.

This probably parallels many people's real-world experience who worked for the USG over the years, people have very idealistic expectations in a complex world. But DS-9 got there first.

What might be interesting in a Section 31 story might be an unrestricted duty Star Fleet officer getting Section 31 to take a more moral approach, while accomplishing a mission. Sort of "getting to Kirk" becoming someone who bends rules while upholding a moral code . . . .

Ответить
@smlambert9418
@smlambert9418 - 03.02.2025 22:33

This is a horrible movie

Ответить
@williamschweikert5492
@williamschweikert5492 - 03.02.2025 08:21

Star Trek Section 31 brought to you by........
People that want viewers to change the channel.
Yet another all time low achievement for Kurtzman Trek. Well as Discovery fans say that Discovery was written for a progressive audience and not actual Star Trek fans what in the name of @#$%^& what audience was this written for??

Ответить
@mercuryinformatica1073
@mercuryinformatica1073 - 02.02.2025 23:08

Does anyone have any information on Sheldon Cooper? He’s not answering his phone.

Ответить
@MovieRecapTvofficial
@MovieRecapTvofficial - 02.02.2025 17:52

this movie shouldn't be called star trek it is the worst 😒 it should be call galaxy gaze it's not star trek like 😑

Ответить
@-Susso
@-Susso - 02.02.2025 08:56

Rachel Garret may have been related to the character in TNG, which is the only thing I saw that was related to Star Trek ... just sayin'

Ответить
@rhadiem
@rhadiem - 02.02.2025 06:51

-20/10

Ответить
@rhadiem
@rhadiem - 02.02.2025 06:43

That Star Trek girl is the epitome of every hardcore lib I've ever met.

Ответить
@rhadiem
@rhadiem - 02.02.2025 06:39

This sucks so bad. Everyone associated should be extremely embarrassed. Shame is a very useful experience that helps people reflect and improve.

Ответить
@deslardesslok
@deslardesslok - 02.02.2025 02:50

VERY SLIGHTLY OVER A WEEK LATE SQUAD WHERE YOU AT?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?

Ответить
@deslardesslok
@deslardesslok - 02.02.2025 02:49

8 DAYS LATE SQUAD WHERE YOU AT?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?

Ответить
@deslardesslok
@deslardesslok - 02.02.2025 02:49

6:49p.m. 2/1/2025

Ответить
@scarystardust6095
@scarystardust6095 - 01.02.2025 13:28

Star trek, star wars, marvel are all deceased. Let's move on to something else or even something new. Is that too much to ask?

Ответить
@Bob-cu8no
@Bob-cu8no - 01.02.2025 10:46

It was absolute shite

Ответить
@mremington8
@mremington8 - 01.02.2025 10:38

this thing is genuinely beyond awful
couldn't even finish watching it

Ответить
@c7u3676
@c7u3676 - 31.01.2025 18:19

Thanks for saving me the time.

Ответить
@SalmonOfTheKnowledgeable
@SalmonOfTheKnowledgeable - 31.01.2025 17:16

Hate the urine cinematography trend

Ответить
@keggs73
@keggs73 - 31.01.2025 16:26

I gave it a watch , but I didn't even make it to the end.
I haven't enjoyed S-T since star trek enterprise!!

Ответить
@davidmiedema2950
@davidmiedema2950 - 31.01.2025 07:05

It was worse than stargate origins...

Ответить
@cartwright8920
@cartwright8920 - 31.01.2025 01:54

Rachel Garrett was captain of the Enterprise C in TNG Yesterday's Enterprise.

Ответить
@JasonJones-l1n
@JasonJones-l1n - 30.01.2025 21:08

When star trek turned into shit!!!

Ответить
@donaldbensen146
@donaldbensen146 - 30.01.2025 18:11

It was worse than Star Trek 5, Nemesis, and the Spock’s Brain episode combined. “Brain, brain, brain what is brain!?” It was bad.

Ответить
@mitchellmelkin4078
@mitchellmelkin4078 - 30.01.2025 15:41

Of course, one can't hear some of what's being said at times because these guys are, you know, Section 31, being secretive and all. Allegedly. 🙄 🙄 🙄

Ответить
@HighHeelKnight
@HighHeelKnight - 30.01.2025 12:46

I only watched Section 31 because of Michelle Yeoh.
I have been mesmerized by her since Tomorrow Never Dies
😍😍😍😍😍

Ответить