Vocal Reaction & Critique | Haley Reinhart - Creep - Postmodern Jukebox Radiohead Cover

Terry, I totally agree with your comment regarding Haley and Angelina Jordan. This may be the greatest vocal performance ever. I would like to add Morgan James to the list.

The current vocalist performing Creep on this 2023 PMJ tour is Effie Passero, her remarkable interpretation is also next level greatness, remember her name👍

Haley is Awesome !! so is Morgan James PMJ both do songs together Check it out!

Love Radiohead (went to see them in Dublin) & despise 'Creep' with every fiber of my being (tjezus we poor teens were terrorized by it in the 90s, drove entire nations to collective suicide and ruin). Bizarrely; absolutely love this cover by Haley Reinhard. Am i goin' mad !? It's like the Martians have landed after all.

a masterpiece performance. This + PMJ's "Dream on" w/Morgan James are my favs from PMJ..definitely check that one out as well if you haven't already!

I’ve loved Haley ever since she was on American Idol. She didn’t win that season, but she’s considered by many to be the breakout star of the season (and has arguably had a much stronger career than whoever did win). I don’t know if i would call her a “mainstream success”, but she seems to be very happy in the lane she’s in, because she’s a really unique, old soul and has a really loyal following among those that do appreciate her talent.

Haley doing Mad World. with PPP.

FYI, her family pronounces it "Rhine Heart".... she took 3rd place in AI season 10 and was robbed.... the 1st and 2nd place were both younger country artists (both very good). However, NOT winning is good for folks like Haley, Daughtry, & Adam Lambert and others who are better off without those contracts and commitments. I love Haley's voice. Everything she has done w/ PMJ is amazing. The other great vocalist that w/ PMJ is Morgan James and her cover over "Dream On" is stunning. there is one PMG with both Haley and Morgan and 3rd vocalist and her AI friend playing upright bass.

Saw her live singing this and it took my breath away!

Yay you are doing all my favourite videos haha love people discovering amazing talent like this

Love Haley. I watched three seasons of Idol; hers was one of them. I really like Scotty, the winner, but Haley should have won because her talent is through the roof.

This is the one that gets all the attention (>100MM views), but she knocks others out of the park as well. Check out her PMJ covers of "Seven Nation Army", "Habits", "Black Hole Sun" and "Don't Speak".
PMJ itself is a deep rabbit hole: Right up there with Haley is Morgan James ("Maps", "Dream On", "Take Me to Church".) Or catch them both in "All About That Bass".

Inside voice: Screw you. I don’t care what you say!
Outside voice: GOING BACK!

Are u a vocalist Nick?

🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

She had you before she finished first verse, just like the rest of us. ENJOY THE JOURNEY 😊

When Haley is done singing, you feel like you need a cigarette in a cold shower....

I wish PMJ's other version of this song with Karen Marie got more love.

Haley is the most impressive singer I know of. She has so many great songs with PMJ and without. But I highly recommend her (and PMJ's) cover of Tove Lo's "Habits". It's amazing. And there are very few reactions to it, not sure if that's just because the original isn't that well known. If you reacted to it you would be one of the few and largest reactors with a reaction to it. It deserves some lovin.

Yeah...this is absolutely Haley's song now. Radiohead who? This is very much like Johnny Cash's version of Hurt in that regard.

Check out My "Baby Just Cares For Me" By Jeff Goldblum Ft. Haley Reinhart.

I was actually pissed off that she didn’t win idol!! Scotty McQueary is good ! He’s a country male singer who has had a great career but Hailey sings circles around SM or anyone else on season 10 of idol. I’m not biased I just think she’s the best singer that’s came along in 50 years! And why she’s not selling out stadiums is beyond me

There is a reason the PMJ video has 116M views.

PMJ "discovers" so many great vocalists.........Scott Bradlee, the pianist, arranges most, if not all, the covers.......this is straight outta' a 1950's jazz club and Hayley, well, she's just Hayley.......

Whoa!!!!! She is outstanding, if she is the one I remember on Idol she was left go to early. On Idol she performed House of the Rising Sun, and she blew everyone away

Haley’s voice is otherworldly. She transports you to another time, place, and reality. She takes you on an entire journey, captivates your heart with her soul and grips your mind with her musicality and doesn’t let go. She truly makes you forget where you are and what you’re doing other than listening to her pour out everything in here and now. I love her. Please listen to more Haley! Loves your reaction!!!

Grato!!!

She was sick with sore throat and didn’t think she could do this and they did it in one take

1920’s dive bar jessica rabbit

Please please react to her cover of “I put a spell on you” it is so incredible live!!!!

Maybe you just aren't awae but Scott Bradlee (on piano) is the GENIUS behind PMJ. He comes up with the arrangement and then these fantastic (but mostly little known) artists come out and astound us with their performances. And let's not forget the musicians that back up the singers. All in all, PMJ is fabulous. You really need to check out their cover of All About That Bass, Dream On, Feel It Still, Ain't No Rest For the Wicked; and so many more. They take a song and give an entirely new twist.

Reinhart as in Rhinehart

Please check out PMJ' s cover of Aerosmith's " Dream on". Featuring Morgan James. It is so good. 💯💥

Love your reactions! If you want to see Hailey Rinehart in her undeniable style (like no other) - check out PostModern Jukebox with her version of “I Did it Again”
- trust me -there is NO WAY to prepare you for it at all! No way! Best to you.

Made it her own? Yes. This is an amazing performance. I can't say Haley is my 'very very favorite, nor is PMJ. But THIS? THIS performance, this song, this day... is one of the best vocal and instrumental performances I have ever heard. By anyone. Ever. I'm happy you reacted and enjoyed! The unexpected is usually the most fun AND exciting!! Great reaction!

I like this better than the original. I've been listening to this version for 5 or 6 years.

That's what I like about Morrisette Amon as well. She has a 5.5 octave range.

Wonder how Radiohead likes the fact that she does a better version then they did. She owns this song.

Listen to Emma kok singing viola at 15. It's in french and that's not her language

You are going to have to watch that a few more times to get the full meal deal on this one.

Jessica Rabbit's more talented sister.

Brian Justin Crumb's version is so much better

She made me cry.

I just love Haley and PMJ's version of Take me to church too.

I think she did a better job than radio head

Hailey is incredible and has other contributions the PMJ that are well worth checking out. For my money, though, Morgan James' cover of "Dream On" with PMJ is the pinnacle. That's taking nothing away from Hailey; she is a once in a lifetime vocalist. So is Morgan James, just with a differing style. Of course you could do yourself a real favor and check out both of them working with PMJ on "All About that Bass". You can't go wrong with either.

It is not Rein not rain, I hoped to hear you correct yourself before the end of you video reaction.

5 genius dudes and a girl singing like her life depends on it. A one take masterpiece.

It is quintessential jazz.