So I'm not picking sides YET, but im starting to definitely believe that mel is innocent a bit more ngl. Though here's the opinion, First off timothy did all of this way back during the crybaby tour, and then got CAUGHT lying....., also she did this whenever melanie became more popular just like rn melanie became popular again, and she does it again, Second I saw a video of one of Timothy's old friends saying that melanie tried to contact timothy, but yk what timothy decided to do instead of letting melanie talk about it w her, she decides to post it on the internet, and in the video her old friends says that timothy said that it would be funny which ofc it wasn't. Lastly, timothy is a adult she could have handled this much better than the internet especially with the melanie trying to contact her thing, but also if this situation is that bad for her she could SOMEHOW deal this in court ik it would be hard but its better than the internet ngl also didnt miss gurl say sm like "i just want everythingto calm down and this wont be an issue anymore." LIKE gurl, you brought it put again. You made it more of an issue, gurlie *correct me if im wrong about if she said that or not, i dont remember correctly*. Now, this is just a little thing here, so just bc melanie didn't respond yet. DOES NOT mean she's instantly guilty she does kinda need time to reply, especially of her touring rn. Though I don't have many more opinions on this rn, I hope that melanie is innocent and that this situation gets better. *little note, Toxic melanie fans need to STOP, ok, just bc if timothy is lying you do not get permission to doxx her, leak number, death threats, or ETC, that's not what a true melanie fan would do bc you would know melanie does not want those kind of toxic fans or toxic fans in general, just leave her alone w that kind of stuff.*