NFL Rookie QB Grades: High ceiling for Caleb Williams, BIG expectations for Jayden Daniels & MORE

How is caleb a c+ when literally all 3 rookie qbs have the same exact stats
Jayden 3,045 yds 217 per game 17 tds
Caleb 2,937 yds 209 per game 17 tds with one of the worse offensive lines in football and still has less Ints
Whos the producer writing this show i would like a conversation with them

This video is a joke. You say you’re gonna grade the quarterbacks based on their first year then immediately talk about how good Caleb was at college and give him a positive grade because you have faith in him going into the future.

If you look at his actual performance this year it’s like a C. He gets sacked, he holds the ball too long and doesn’t take enough shots down field. An A or B+ quarterback should be able to get victories and overcome his obstacles. Instead, we’re making more excuses for Caleb because it didn’t work out and failed to meet the expectations of the media.

Excuse after excuse for Caleb Williams. Pundits just don't wanna be wrong about their "generational talent". For now, he's not who you thought he was, and until further notice, he's far from it.

A b+ for Williams. You lost all credibility. No need to watch the rest of the video.

Caleb is a C
Jayden is a A+
Drake is a B+
Bo is a A-

If you say anything but an A+ for JD5 you havent watched enough washington football...

Caleb has to learn to make post snap reads while in the pocket. He didn't do it much in college and wasn't a pocket passer like
Penix Jr. learned out necessity at Washington to save his body.

Haha Caleb gets his head coach and OC fired and it is not his fault! Grade of C is highest you can give him this year!

B+ is somebody who was able to get his team to .500 atleast despite all the organization malfunction. Caleb is not that guy.

If Caleb gets a B+ then Jayden shouldn't even be grouped with the rest of these rookies.

This was dumb!

Just so everyone has the correct information because I hate when people say misleading things....the qbs that have the same amount of picks as Nix are cousins, Mayfield, Winston, Smith, Levi's, mahomes, Darnold, love, and Richardson. Goff, minshew, maye, Purdy, stroud, and young have 1 or 2 less. Nix and cousins do not have way more interceptions than the other qbs. Over 20 qbs have 8 or more picks. Let's just say honest things please.

Even with Jaydeen before the season started the Commanders were only given 3 wins.

I am a Washington fan. Y’all im the comments are proof of how short-sighted NFL fans are. Caleb is in a horrendous situation. Y’all are the same people that probably said Darnold and Mayfield were talentless or that Russ was finished. Team fit and personnel are SO important. I’d give Caleb a B.

Giving Drake Maye the same grade as record breaking JD5 is Krspy Kreme like glaze.

Jayden was out a game 13 starts

Are you kidding me...a B+ ? You need to check your eyes Sir. Caleb looks mediocre to me. Nice try though. HTTC

Caleb Williams…2937, 17tds, 5 int
Jayden Daniels…3045, 17 tds, 6 int
Bo Nix…2972, 20 tds, 11 int
Drake Maye…1898, 12 yds, 9 int

Now throw the other 3 qbs in this Bear dumpster fire.

Using Ryan Wilson's logic, so far this season, I give Jaden Daniels an A+++ because he too has a chance to be special if newly hired GM Adam Peters give him more weapons and o-line support.
Grade today's current performance on a glimpse and the anticipation of tomorrow's decisions, acquisitions and performance projections. Got to love it! 😀

I assume John intended to exclude the fact that Caleb’s “two great games before the bye” were against the two worst defenses in the league… I don’t believe that’s a coincidence.

how the fuck you gonna grade caleb a b+ because you have faith in him with the right coach and coordinator 😂😂😂 ryan wilson a fucking clown

you’re grading them off this season and how they’ve played and caleb gets a b+ becuase this dumbass has faith in him NEXT YEAR

ryan wilson a bum

they pay these people to have the worst takes possible lmfao only ball knowledge these guys got is dick n balls

Jayden is an A+ he went to a 4 win team and has them at 9 this year with the potential to get 12

All the excuses for every qb except Nix. They have a 70M dead cap anchor. They almost 100M less invested into their offense as compared to the Chief's

B+ caleb delusional

Fired coaches is not the reason Caleb is bad. He's bad, that's the reason coaches got fired in the first place. I'm not saying the coaches aren't bad, but with better QB play they probably don't get fired.

I'm an LSU fan but, undoubtedly JD5 is the best quarterback of this bunch and that was before the draft. I watched every snap of his at LSU and it was clear he was the best player in the draft. I prayed the Bears didn't take Jayden 1st overall because they are a horribly run organization. Caleb is not a bust. He's trying to do too much at times. These are growing pains. He got away with things in college that are not going to fly in the NFL. I never thought he was a generational talent but, the young man is talented. Bo Nix, I thought he landed with the perfect coach in Sean Payton based on the type of offense Payton has always ran. People joke about his age but Bo has been phenomenal this year too. Drake Maye is not in an ideal situation right now either. Let's judge these guys in 3 years and see how much progression they've all made. Give these young men some grace.

Caleb B+? Talk about hitting the holiday moonshine hard huh.

We can all agree none of these idiots should be on tv. Stop watching after they said Drake mate should get a A- and Caleb gets a B like wtf

JD is an A++. He’s among the best quarterbacks in the league. Watch the breakdown films. That A- that was bumped up to A was said by a clown

Caleb haters dont realize rhat williams has almost the same atta as daniels an nox behind a terrible oline an sone really dumb coaches but keep following the media u sheep

a B+ for Caleb is absolutely hysterical. He has gotten WORSE, not better. Generational talent? lol no. D+ is the rating.

Jayden Daniels is the best rookie QB the NFL has ever seen and with his physical gifts the ceiling is genuinely limitless. A++

Bo Nix is a checkdown merchant and a turnover machine. C+

Drake Maye is what we thought he would be at this point: a loser. C-

JD5 is awfully solid and has a 4 win team in contention for a playoff spot. When you put some weapons around him he's gonna really shine. Tough kid, humble too. High ceiling

b+ for williams? Are you kidding me..more like a C+

Caleb has Same amount of passing TDs, less interceptions, averages 8 less yards per game passing. How is one A+ and the other C- lol ?

These commentators are clowns 🤡

Jayden is A+
Bo nix is A
Caleb Williams is B or B+
Drake Maye is B-

ONLY a C+ for Caleb. What a joke.

No way he said the bears line isn’t horrible

C+ dumb.... the only thing that you mentioned that is on Caleb is sacks. Show me besides Jaden daniels and stroud that a rookie had better numbers. Stupid. On such a dysfunctional team. Then for the other guy to give drake Maye an A- to a guy that has worse numbers than Caleb because you didn't think he should start this year. Even more dumb analysis. Well not watching these clowns anymore.

You try playing for the Bears and see how you do