Those who say follow QURAN ONLY | Mufti Menk Lectures | NON MUSLIM REACTION

yo guy in color , its not to follow ure brother can do it easaly , u are just stupid

such a Cancer for world.....this is a evil indeed...

Quranists are a misguided group they are not Muslims and their number is so small that you can count them on your fingers Because their faith is completely different from the two billion Muslims around the world. Because if someone claims to be a Quranist he cannot follow Islam because Quran only mentions major things but the Hadith provide details about every single thing including the five daily prayers and the five pillars of Islam.

🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰❤️❤️❤️

99% muslim believes in Hadith, and supported top Hadith books

Please brothers, you need to know we don’t say Allah peace be upon we only say peace be upon for messengers. Encourage what you’re doing guys, May Allah guide us all. I enjoyed your show as well.

The brother in black tee short is more sincere than the clown guy who's trying to be smart but exposing his ignorance. To learn be humble , stop bitching .

React to HAMZA YUSUF

Accept only the hadiths that do not contradict the Quran. It is that simple.

That massage was for Muslims Not for you guys

Justin’s arrogance can be a little off-putting at times, but I really appreciate James’ perspective on things. It’s James that keeps me subbed to this channel. Thank you 😊

LAUREL AND HARDY YOU DONT KNOW WHAT YOU TALKING ABOUT

GO AND STUDY ISLAM

Thank you for this reaction 🥰🥰🥰

You guys should react to quran from start to end surah by surah...

❤ Everyone say:
33 subhanallah
33 alhmadulillah
34 allahuakber

Tamraj kilvish why you use so aggressive hateful comment?looks like you got cancer of evil inside you so much so that you have nothing but only bitter anger, toxicity left in you.

Army of Satan is your genre. Bring them back asap

Stop comparing to your experiences with Christianity!!!! Defeated way to learn

He can't focus that's why he chooses his whims and desires over reason and evidence.

Pov from an intp..stop reacting to islam videos just to gain views!!

Quran alone is true Islam. And Mufti Menk has been refuted by Quran alone Muslims easily

Hi Guys, Justin you look at his beard and his thoup, but you don’t look at what you wear, baby 👕. It's not suitable for you.😂😂😂😂

By the way, Justin we call to all prophets (PBUH) not only our prophet Mohammed. And please show respect for all.😡

I feel like James comes with a little more openness to the subject and knows how to take the information and deal with it without influencing it too much with his previous experiences, while Justin seems more angry, closed off and likes to put his preconceived ideas of what religions are when reacting to these kinds of videos sometimes. Its not very serious but it does put me off sometimes, as a believer i feel judged and seen like a brainwashed sheep who follows blindly and doesn't know better than religion while james does 😂😂😂not that it really matters to me but i just felt the need to comment this as constructive criticism cause i do believe that since Justin is willing to learn about all these religions, he isn't that close minded and he just need to hear this maybe 😂😂 other than this i do really enjoy your videos, i find them very constructive and its nice hear someone's opinion from outside our religion keep going ! 🤍🤍🤍

No hadiths in holy prophets time , prophet didn't follow hadith only the koran ,which is hadith in itself

O my dear brother you reaton this video treatment for parent in Islam one Allah TV with English subtitles by mufti Menk with English subtitles you will be caring this video brother you don't miss this video

There are lots of misconception regarding these themes. So we all should be careful. Any narration conflict or against Quran ayas should be rejected.

If you guys are serious about educating yourselves you must check out

Dr Mohamed Shahroor


He is the revolution today

Hadeeth is not necessary as specified in the Quran itself



God explicitly said

وما فرطنا به في شيء

This means ALL that you need is in the book

If you start to follow Hadeeth then how different are you from the Christians?

They follow a Bible that they admit it's not God's word!

If you follow just Hadeeth you are doing the same thing as Christians

Besides all hadeeths are riddled with Israelites!!



RIP DR MOHAMED SHAHROOR ❤

No real muslim will exclude hadith thats a fact.
Authentic hadith is known and there r books for authentic hadiths
Hadith is a complete science on its own and a huge field and there always been qualified people in that field centuries ago with Phds and complete dedication to it and all contributed to wat we have now of known books and we know wats authentic and wats not
So simple .dont know y some people just liks to complicate things unless they have a hidden agenda behind such weird opinions

You don't say Allah peace be upon him. For Allah you say the most holy the most high. But you're not muslims anyways, so you don't need to do all these praise and respect. For muslims, mentioning a prophet's name without adding the 'peace be upon him' behind the name is considered arrogant/ high in pride. And when mentioning Allah, we don't have to add anything behind the name but we muslims praise the God a lot so we add those praise words and sometimes every one of His 99 attributes: The most holy, The most high, The greatest, etc.

Beautiful Islam Quran my Ferind

Bro cmon get over christiany and look at things from a new perspective stop comparing and droping everything onto your past christian experiences

the hadidth contain of what prophet spoke to sahabah(companion), what shabah saw prophet doing things, and many more action of the prophet. This thing being record for future generation to knowing what prophet do and done back then to follow him as Quran instructed us to do. While this all being narated by the companion of prophet. Scholar double check triple check, fourth check and so on to unsure it is legitimate and aunthenticity.

Pls change your profail gays

This man guy is a big liar and he knows how to fool and talk sweet enough to make people fooled. I'm not sure what you guys know about Hadith or Quran or what you guys follow but you'll have to understand the basics once you do you will figure out how this mank guy is lying through his teeth. It's how wonderful to see how these lying scholars are getting so much money to open schools have mansions and two or three cars It's pretty interesting don't you think

Dude like how these who follow only Quran pray , praying was mentioned in Quran but it doesn't explain how many rakas to pray each Salah and number of prayers their exact timing

The two of you do a good job of presenting and critiquing the videos you choose to curate. And each of you brings your own skills. James selects and presents ideas he is curious about, with openness and honesty, and Justin offers more questions, critical thinking and a healthy dose of skepticism. Both are like a yin and yang and work well together and that seems to be the strength of your videos, imo. Truth withstands all scrutiny and, If not, well it's not truth, whether in the Qur'an or Hadith, the OT or NT, the Torah or Talmud. Expose all texts, teachings, history, claims and beliefs to scholarship and criticism and let's see how they all hold up. Good show, fellas.

I’ve watched a fair share of your reactions to Islamic videos, and one thing that stands out is the arrogance that often marks the start of these reactions. Instead of approaching the content with an open mind or even a shred of curiosity, there’s an obvious lack of focus or willingness to engage thoughtfully. No effort is made to study or understand the depth of the material presented.

And yet, despite repeated exposure to meaningful content, some people just don’t change. Take Justin, for example. He’s still as rude and condescending as ever. Instead of addressing the ideas or engaging with the subject matter, he seems more interested in superficial judgments. Why waste time focusing on what someone looks like? There’s absolutely nothing wrong with the man’s presentation—he’s articulate and composed. Meanwhile, the criticism comes from someone sporting a kindergarten-level teddy bear shirt. How does that even make sense? It’s hypocritical and frankly undermines any claim to credibility or maturity. If you’re going to criticize, at least come prepared with substance, not this childish mockery.

May Allah guide you Mr. James, you seem inquisitive enough to keep exploring Islam. You might be receiving some backlash for y'all's videos, but you keep looking into Islam nonetheless. My one advice, tackle the arguments and the points. It's easy to dismiss everything under the viel of "religion", but as you dig deeper into Islam you'll realize this is very different to Christianity. Don't take me word for it, just keep doing your research. Try to put aside some bias that chrisitianity perhaps imparted on y'all. I understand as I grew up in the south, the Church can be somewhat unforgiving to those who ask questions and research, Islam is not like this.

Again don't take my word for it, just continue to research, and look at the evidences, logic, and facts. Life has an objective Truth, it's up to us to do our due diligence to find it.

be respect full
when you talk about your creator

here you are not talking about a man
you are talking about almighty GOD (ALLAH)
be smart

عَنْ مَالِك أَنَّ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ قَالَ تَرَكْتُ فِيكُمْ أَمْرَيْنِ لَنْ تَضِلُّوا مَا تَمَسَّكْتُمْ بِهِمَا كِتَابَ اللَّهِ وَسُنَّةَ نَبِيِّهِ

“I have left you with two matters which will never lead you astray, as long as you hold to them: the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of his Prophet.”

Source: al-Muwaṭṭa’ 1661

Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Ibn Abdul Barr