Комментарии:
No...NO! They weren't "confident enough that they just walked.". They were ORDERED to WALK! Just like at Paschendale, when, after all that experience, Commonwealth troops were ORDERED, yet again, to WALK.
ОтветитьImagine if as much effort was put in by the establishment and the media in the u.k in asking hard questions about wars in the first place instead of the pomp and ceremony and almost entertainment like value of these commemorations. The first world war was a disgrace of a war that cost the lives of millions on both sides and for what ??. There is a good book people might want to read called War is a lie, by David Swanson. Its a real eye opener
ОтветитьWhen will we see commemorations for the million Iraqi's killed by the Bush / Blair invasion? We will never see commemorations for that.
ОтветитьSuch a sad, sad event. They were ordered to walk over there or they would have had a bullet in their head. So they would of died either way. But this battle was such a tragic way to die.
ОтветитьMy great grandad fought there. Died from his injuries back home.
ОтветитьI think I read somewhere that after that 1st shelling, they then sent infantry in whilst the shelling was still going on. So that the Germans didn't have time to rectify themselves after the bombing stopped. And then it was close quarter combat, and many perished in a most horrible way.
Can anyone confirm if that is correct?
I go to Lochnagar Crater every year (it's a war memorial) 57,000 people died there that day.
ОтветитьI began watching this last night and then went into Wiki to read about Somme?Verdun. Huge is what I learned. "And" (quotations for emphasis) all of the other major battle taking place along the trench lines. Sheesh.
ОтветитьThat first man commented and the others are neglecting the Lack of Dependable and Effective communication. Hmm. EDit: for me, I feel that this was the most important factor. An administrative failure, and rests upon the war planners.
ОтветитьLol, no, they didnt just "walk across no mans land expecting nothing" they had orders to march across no mans land, the Irish had the right idea, take as much gear off and run for it, but still, respect
ОтветитьThe Germans didn't kill them.
The were killed by the ignorance and incompetence of their own generals.
The cream of 'Edwardian' youth from Germany died that day too. 72,000 soldiers? That's only the British. Why cannot documentaries be neutral?
Ответитьhonour and Glory to the german army.!
ОтветитьMy great great uncle fought in the great war. He was a royal engineer. He died on the first of July 1916 with many others. His name is on the Thiepval memorial for the missing. The memorial Has 72,000 names on it. let us not forget those who fought in the war, those of all nations, no matter how history remembers them.
ОтветитьI’ve been to see this in real life and no photo or video can show the shear size of this crater, this is definitely something that everyone should experience, the memorial is spectacular as well! It really puts everything in perspective, RIP to those who gave us the privileges today that we all take for granted sometimes ❤️
ОтветитьHill 60
ОтветитьI was shocked to read how many of my fellow Kiwi lads were at this place. Not the bloodiest. Paschendaele was worse... New Zealand death & casualty rate was the highest of all, after the war - poor beggars.
Ответитьour stupid governments brain our wash people to war and kill eachother just so a few people can gain control in the world , i say we war against these people and take our rightful destiny back and create peace in the world this has gone on for too long and its just gonna get worse .. soo we will all be under complete control and no freedom and no truth
ОтветитьIn those times there commanders only care about victory
ОтветитьVery poor information.
ОтветитьMost people don’t realise how bloody ww1 was. Probably because all publicity is about ww2.. It’s a shame really... these people went through worse than hell.
ОтветитьSad.
ОтветитьÓTIMO DOCUMENTÁRIO DA HISTÓRIA, BRASIL OK.
ОтветитьOdd that so many bodies would be under the ground that people farm and walk on, not even knowing.
ОтветитьThey didn't "expect no resistance" they were told to walk to conserve energy
ОтветитьBless all their heats 😢💔🙏🌹✌️x
ОтветитьThe attack on the German positions was preceded by a week of artillery bombardment, where the British fired around 1.5 million grenades, in addition to ten tunnels dug under German trenches that were filled with explosives of 20 tons each. They thought that reaching the German trenches was going to be a Sunday walk, but the opposite happened, the Germans massacred them.
ОтветитьWe shall remember
Ответить“ Hear the words I sing wars a horrid thing “. Blackadder Goes Forth
ОтветитьLusatnia
ОтветитьVery insightful! Visiting the Somme battlefields is a fascinating experience! Check our video!
ОтветитьI wouldn't call them tactics mate
ОтветитьVery interesting facts
Ответить真情像草原广阔
层层风雨不能阻隔
总有云开 日出时候
万丈阳光照亮你我
真情像梅花开遍
冷冷冰雪不能掩没
就在最冷
枝头绽放
看见春天走向你我
雪花飘飘北风啸啸
天地一片苍茫
一剪寒梅
傲立雪中
只为伊人飘香
爱我所爱无怨无悔
Went to Google maps to see where exactly this battlefield is and the first thing I noticed was a McDonald's on the outskirts of the town of Albert.
ОтветитьLand of free because of "brave"
R.I.P. HEROES✝
HERE FOR SCHOOLWORK UUUUGGGHHHHHHHHH
ОтветитьAnyone know where i can find this kind of quality for the Malins Film? I've never seen that guy running before.... one that gets hit. Usually just a blur moving
ОтветитьSeinfeld war about nothing. Nothing except alliances. For which 20 million paid with their lives.
ОтветитьWhat's the story with that one soldier in the scene where the British soldiers climb the side of the trench in unison to charge. One soldier to the right giving low effort then after merely peaking over the top appears to either be somehow killed or feigning death...
ОтветитьI was the 1,200th like 👍
ОтветитьSo why was everyone fighting ? All cause of the royal families and their egos
Ответить