Комментарии:
This song is amazing, it’s just art. Incredible.
ОтветитьI hate the fashionable but ridiculous use of the word 'THEIR', while it is about 1 person.
ОтветитьBut what is the track right at the very end of the this video?!
ОтветитьCan this song be labelled surreal? Both the lyrics and the music, PARTICULARLY the gorgeous flows of 7/8?
ОтветитьGive up the ghost is a great example of counterpoint(from the basement)
ОтветитьWhy don't you analyse a.r. Rahman and ILLAYARAJA llayaraja songs , which even more mind blowing🤯, the GOAT ' S 🐐 OF TAMIL MUSIC.
ОтветитьDavid finally breaking down my all time favorite song, today is a good day
ОтветитьI don't think calling this an episodic song has much explanatory power at all.
To me, it's better to think of as an instrumental chorus song. The "first section" are the two verses. The "second section" is the first two choruses, the first being the riff just on an acoustic and the second when the distorted guitar joins in (the fact that there is singing over part of it is kind of irrelevant, many instrumental choruses have some unobtrusive vocal work to accompany the centerpiece) The "third section" is the bridge. And the reprise of the second section is the final chorus.
This has the benefit of acknowledging that each of these sections behave as you expect in a standard song. The verses are quiet, the lowest energy of the song, and divide pretty cleanly into verse-prechorus configurations (a second immediately repeating verse before the first chorus is also a common strategy.) The chorus is higher energy, catchier, and each builds on the energy of the previous while being periodically recurring. They are clearly the focal point of the song. And the bridge is a much slower build into the final chorus (it's also modulating which is common for bridges but every section modulates so that doesn't mean much.)
Obviously, there's a substantial deviation from the standard verse-chorus structure as one would expect from Radiohead. But it goes a much longer way to explaining how those parts actually fit together and are heard. This isn't Bohemian Rhapsody.
Very instructive video thank you ! Any idea on why, according to the couterpoint melody, Ed is not singing backing vocals until the "that's it Sir line" live ?
ОтветитьFantastic. I had no idea of the counterpoint going on in the song, but it all makes sense now.
ОтветитьGood job i like this song
ОтветитьNice work David, one of my Radiohead favourites - I always felt that the E alternates to Esus4 before the A Cm in the slow section
ОтветитьBrilliant analysis of a fantastic song
ОтветитьThe only problem with this video is that I'm gonna drop it to listen to Paranoid Android now
ОтветитьThank you.
ОтветитьParanoid Android is one of the greatest pieces of music ever written. It's one of the few examples of contemporary music that will likely still feel interesting and noteworthy to people centuries in the future.
ОтветитьMy player skipped back like 10 seconds after you said "it gives a skipped record feel" and I thought you did something really clever/cute lmao
ОтветитьThe slow section always reminds me of Elton John's "Funeral for a Friend / Love Lies Bleeding."
ОтветитьAwesome video, as usual. Thanks so much!
Now, if you ever felt like analysing Sinéad O'Connor's "In this heart" it'd make me SO happy. 🙏😄
Thanks for this analysis of a brilliant piece!
ОтветитьIf you think about it, Paranoid Android has kind of a symphony structure
ОтветитьI don’t hear the E -> A -> Cm as a secondary dominant, dominant, tonic. I hear it as a dominant, tonic, tonic. It sounds more like a key change.
ОтветитьI first heard this song for the closing credits of one of my favorite anime shows, Ergo Proxy. It is an alternate reality show, I think is in the future and it’s about their robot assistants they call auto-raves and part of the robots contract a virus that gives them consciousness. It’s worth the watch only one season and the English voice acting in my opinion is very good. The closing credit song really puts the show in a neat (imo) perspective. ☺️☺️
ОтветитьSimply brutal.
ОтветитьI never seem to get tired of Paranoid Android analysis
ОтветитьThis should have gone on for another hour! More please.
ОтветитьI’d love to hear a cover of Paranoid Android by Sabrina Carpenter…
…or Rebecca Black.
I was today years old when I found out the fat guy with the mask and axe in the music video was Boris Yeltsin...
ОтветитьPretty Things “In the Square” ripoff tbf
Ответитьmeh. overrated band and song.
ОтветитьEven if Radiohead are not comfortable about this tag, for me this is the prog rock masterpiece of the '90s. I remember not liking it the first time and loving it more after each listen. Although the ending still feels too abrupt to me.
ОтветитьThank you for this video
Ответитьthe slow tempo section sounds like 'Mellohi' from Minecraft by c418
ОтветитьI'm hopeful that one day Radiohead will come out with another good song--I haven't heard a good one of theirs since High and Dry.
ОтветитьI love how the third part seems safer every time
ОтветитьGreat stuff 👍
ОтветитьMan, the progression in this song is absolutely gorgeous.
ОтветитьFinally!! This is my favourite Radiohead song and I'm so glad you're talking about it!!!
ОтветитьI remember the first time I heard this song. I was driving in my car in probably December of 1998 and had to pull off the road because my brain was melting. Safety first 😂
Ответитьgosh, i think my favourite part of this song is that last chord progression. it feels like an inverse Shepard's tone, constantly falling and falling deeper into despair.
Ответитьplease change the thumbnail i really didn't want to click on it lmao
ОтветитьHey David! Do you plan on making more videos where you create original songs or recreate existing ones? Those are some of the ones i enjoy the most from you
Cheers
Radiohead's feeling for sounds is simply unbelievable.
And, the song (like every RH song) is far from being over-produced. Chords, melody, the whole composition speak for itself.
Hey DBP you should do one on Happiness is a Warm Gun.
ОтветитьNo analysis - or even an acknowledgement - of the guitar solos? 😢
Ответить"Never appeared in any other song" is a large statement but I'll take it with salt for this song
Ответить